{ "semanticHash": "8cfe3e01eb882b5713e7bf96fca274a6f8bdd839fc48aeb9ed367187fc4cd12e", "experiments": { "version": "curated-composition-v1", "kernel": { "version": "event-support-v1", "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition" }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report" } ], "scope": "The finite event-support model through t10. Catastrophe refers to the reporting branch, not every possible harm. Incidence paths retain all/any/not and actor-information logic in the replay rather than treating an arrow as a sufficient cause." }, "catalogue": [ { "id": "delay-shepherd", "title": "Delay the Shepherd’s testimony", "category": "revelation-timing", "question": "What if the final identifying answer comes later?", "original": "The Shepherd answers at t7, before recognition at t8.", "changed": "The final answer moves from t7 to t11; the original comparison ends at t10.", "whySelected": "Separates the timing of recognition from the survival of its evidential mechanism. This is the original validated experiment.", "forkAt": "t7", "applicableWhen": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": false } ] }, "operation": { "kind": "legacy-timing", "intervention": "delay-shepherd", "rule": "rule-testimony" }, "assumptions": [ "The final answer moves from t7 to t11; the original comparison ends at t10.", "The inquiry, the Shepherd and his memory remain in place. Later recognition reuses existing rules in a separately labeled continuation.", "Jocasta has already inferred the identity; the timing of her death is not derived from the timing of public recognition." ], "compatibility": { "exclusiveResource": "rule-testimony", "requiresForkPreconditions": true, "explanation": "A delay requires an active parentage inquiry and cannot coexist with permanent withholding." }, "conclusion": { "title": "The tragedy is delayed, not defeated.", "summary": "Oedipus misses the original moment of recognition. His pursuit and the final witness remain, so the most supported continuation brings recognition back later. The catastrophic sequence remains plausible; Jocasta’s earlier realization has already put her at risk.", "supportedBy": [ "delay-return", "delay-catastrophe" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "delay-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The last identifying answer arrives later.", "because": "Moving the only final parentage transfer beyond the comparison window leaves testimony false and the parentage report undelivered.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "unscheduled" } ] }, { "id": "delay-recognition", "section": "engine", "title": "Recognition and its reporting branch do not fire on schedule.", "because": "The recognition rule needs both persistence and the final testimony. With that conjunction false, recognition does not fire; the report then lacks its recognized input.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "delay-pressure", "section": "engine", "title": "The search still has a destination.", "because": "Waiting is selected because testimony is absent, while the accepted adoption account, handover report and the Shepherd’s memory all survive. Jocasta has already reached her own inference.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-recognition" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "delay-delivery", "section": "projection", "title": "The witness supplies the missing answer later.", "because": "The selected condition defers delivery to t11; it does not erase the witness or his access to the remembered handover. Continuing the scheduled transfer is the smallest extension of this state.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-pressure" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-testimony" } ], "applyRule": "rule-testimony" }, { "id": "delay-return", "section": "projection", "title": "Recognition becomes possible again.", "because": "The delivered parentage report now joins accepted adoption and the crossroads memory. Every information and decision requirement of the original recognition rule is satisfied.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-delivery" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true } ], "applyRule": "rule-recognize" }, { "id": "delay-catastrophe", "section": "projection", "title": "The tragic mechanism survives.", "because": "With recognition restored and Jocasta already departed, the original reporting branch is supported again in this continuation. This reuses a modeled sequence; it does not make recognition a universal cause of suicide or date Jocasta’s death.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-return" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "recognized", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-catastrophe" } ], "applyRule": "rule-report" } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Was the timing necessary—or the mechanism?", "structuralPremise": "The original window loses both target events, but the same information gates pass again in the continuation.", "reading": "The canonical timing is contingent on one answer. The surviving witness and Oedipus’s persistence make the mechanism harder to escape than its timetable. That distinction concerns this supported continuation, not a proof that every possible future ends alike.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "delay-recognition", "delay-catastrophe" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "Final parentage evidence arrives later.", "Public recognition and the supported reporting sequence move beyond their original checkpoints." ], "preservedSummary": [ "The first six modeled events and the historical killing and marriage.", "Oedipus’s pursuit, adoption belief, murder memory and surviving witness.", "Jocasta’s earlier inference and departure." ], "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review", "method": "Checked against pinned Storr passages and the complete joint replay; authored interpretation, not independent literary peer review. Automated support assertions and metrics are checked on every build.", "sourceRefs": [ "p-intervention", "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-catastrophe" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] } }, { "id": "omit-accusation", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "category": "information-availability", "question": "Does the prophet’s accusation actually carry the recognition?", "original": "Tiresias accuses Oedipus, who rejects the charge.", "changed": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "whySelected": "Tests a vivid but structurally dispensable branch. No later recognition rule requires the accusation.", "forkAt": "t3", "applicableWhen": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true } ] }, "operation": { "kind": "suppress-rule", "rule": "rule-accuse", "persistence": "held" }, "assumptions": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "Only the selected intervention set and its causal consequences differ from the original world.", "A disabled rule removes its complete modeled episode, including its associated information updates; no unmodeled substitute disclosure is inserted." ], "compatibility": { "exclusiveResource": "rule-accuse", "requiresForkPreconditions": false, "explanation": "This condition is held throughout the experiment. Upstream changes may make this condition redundant." }, "conclusion": { "title": "The tragedy survives without the accusation.", "summary": "Oedipus still reaches the same recognition and catastrophe report. The crossroads memory, adoption account and Shepherd’s testimony supply the evidence he eventually accepts; the rejected accusation is not a necessary input.", "supportedBy": [ "seer-recognition", "seer-outcome" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "seer-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The accusation and its rejection disappear.", "because": "Suppressing this bundled episode removes the received accusation and the denial it provokes, without changing Oedipus’s prior commitment to investigate.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-tiresias", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-accused", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true } ] }, { "id": "seer-route", "section": "engine", "title": "The evidence route remains intact.", "because": "The crossroads exchange is enabled by the investigation, not by Tiresias’s speech. The later Messenger and Shepherd episodes therefore still occur.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "seer-input" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-crossroads", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-messenger", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-testimony", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired" } ] }, { "id": "seer-recognition", "section": "engine", "title": "Oedipus reaches the same recognition.", "because": "The rule requires remembered killing, accepted adoption and reported parentage. All three arrive even without the accusation.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "seer-route" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "fired" } ] }, { "id": "seer-outcome", "section": "engine", "title": "The original catastrophe is still reported.", "because": "Completed recognition and Jocasta’s departure satisfy the reporting rule, so both modeled harm dimensions are established in the replay.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "seer-recognition" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "jocasta-dead", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "oedipus-blind", "value": true } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Is saying the truth the same as making it knowable?", "structuralPremise": "Removing the accusation preserves every dependency route to the two target events.", "reading": "A true charge can be dramatically central without being a necessary cause of recognition. Here agency changes when evidence becomes acceptable to Oedipus, not merely when someone speaks the truth.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "seer-route", "seer-outcome" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "Tiresias’s accusation and Oedipus’s immediate denial." ], "preservedSummary": [ "All eight other canonical events.", "Every modeled dependency route into recognition and the catastrophe report.", "The same past, recognition and reported harms." ], "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review", "method": "Checked against pinned Storr passages and the complete joint replay; authored interpretation, not independent literary peer review. Automated support assertions and metrics are checked on every build.", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] } }, { "id": "silence-shepherd", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "category": "information-availability", "question": "What if the final witness never gives the identifying answer?", "original": "The Shepherd eventually identifies the infant’s household.", "changed": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "whySelected": "Contrasts a temporary delay with a held information cut. The witness remains, but the required identifying disclosure does not return.", "forkAt": "t7", "applicableWhen": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": false } ] }, "operation": { "kind": "suppress-rule", "rule": "rule-testimony", "persistence": "held" }, "assumptions": [ "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "Only the selected intervention set and its causal consequences differ from the original world.", "A disabled rule removes its complete modeled episode, including its associated information updates; no unmodeled substitute disclosure is inserted." ], "compatibility": { "exclusiveResource": "rule-testimony", "requiresForkPreconditions": false, "explanation": "This condition is held throughout the experiment. Upstream changes may make this condition redundant." }, "conclusion": { "title": "Recognition becomes avoidable. The harm is not erased.", "summary": "The search continues without the corroboration that completes Oedipus’s recognition. Holding the final answer back breaks that route for as long as the condition is maintained. Jocasta has already inferred the truth, so this is no rescue for the whole household.", "supportedBy": [ "silence-pressure", "silence-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "silence-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The identifying channel stays closed.", "because": "The held condition disables the final testimony rule and its parentage transfer. The Shepherd’s existing memory is preserved; Oedipus never receives its identifying content.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "silence-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The final recognition gate stays closed.", "because": "Persistence alone cannot satisfy the recognition conjunction. Waiting replaces recognition, and the canonical reporting branch does not fire.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "silence-pressure", "section": "projection", "title": "Oedipus still pursues the evidence.", "because": "The intervention changes access to an answer, not his accepted adoption evidence or his resolve to learn his origins. The text supports continued pressure on this same witness.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-plea" } ] }, { "id": "silence-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The inquiry persists without completed self-recognition.", "because": "Restoring the final answer would reverse the selected condition. Keeping the search open uses the existing goal and witness without inventing a substitute disclosure. Jocasta’s prior inference and the historical harms remain.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-pressure" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "recognized", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "present": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-testimony" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Can withholding knowledge prevent responsibility?", "structuralPremise": "A single held disclosure cuts the modeled recognition pathway, while Jocasta’s inference and the historical harms survive.", "reading": "Recognition is contingent on access to evidence; the acts being recognized are not. Blocking self-knowledge interrupts this public reckoning without undoing what Oedipus has done or what Jocasta already understands.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "silence-cut", "silence-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The final parentage disclosure is persistently blocked.", "The recognition and catastrophe-report routes lose a required input." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Investigation, accepted adoption and the witness’s memory.", "Jocasta’s separate inference and departure.", "The killing and marriage before the play." ], "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review", "method": "Checked against pinned Storr passages and the complete joint replay; authored interpretation, not independent literary peer review. Automated support assertions and metrics are checked on every build.", "sourceRefs": [ "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] } }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "category": "action-prevention", "question": "What if the king does not undertake the inquiry?", "original": "Oedipus acts on the reported mandate and begins investigating.", "changed": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "whySelected": "Tests an upstream decision/action gate rather than withholding a late clue. The oracle report and its public demand remain.", "forkAt": "t2", "applicableWhen": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": false } ] }, "operation": { "kind": "suppress-rule", "rule": "rule-investigate", "persistence": "held" }, "assumptions": [ "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "Only the selected intervention set and its causal consequences differ from the original world.", "A disabled rule removes its complete modeled episode, including its associated information updates; no unmodeled substitute disclosure is inserted." ], "compatibility": { "exclusiveResource": "rule-investigate", "requiresForkPreconditions": false, "explanation": "This condition is held throughout the experiment. Upstream changes may make this condition redundant." }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Is avoiding revelation the same as escaping tragedy?", "structuralPremise": "Disabling the opening action cuts both target pathways with one intervention; the reported civic demand is retained.", "reading": "The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The investigation action and its downstream discoveries.", "Recognition and the canonical catastrophe report do not occur in the modeled sequence." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon’s report and the city’s demand for an answer.", "The historical killing and marriage.", "No replacement investigator, cure or new punishment is introduced." ], "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review", "method": "Checked against pinned Storr passages and the complete joint replay; authored interpretation, not independent literary peer review. Automated support assertions and metrics are checked on every build.", "sourceRefs": [ "p-oracle", "p-quest" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] } }, { "id": "no-messenger", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "category": "encounter-condition", "question": "What if the Corinthian Messenger never meets Oedipus?", "original": "The Messenger’s encounter supplies the death report, adoption account and infant handover lead.", "changed": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "whySelected": "Removes a knowledge bridge between a murder inquiry and a search for birth identity. This targets the actual bundled encounter in the IR, not an invented single clue.", "forkAt": "t5", "applicableWhen": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": false } ] }, "operation": { "kind": "suppress-rule", "rule": "rule-messenger", "persistence": "held" }, "assumptions": [ "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "Only the selected intervention set and its causal consequences differ from the original world.", "A disabled rule removes its complete modeled episode, including its associated information updates; no unmodeled substitute disclosure is inserted." ], "compatibility": { "exclusiveResource": "rule-messenger", "requiresForkPreconditions": false, "explanation": "This condition is held throughout the experiment. Upstream changes may make this condition redundant." }, "conclusion": { "title": "The murder inquiry loses its route into parentage.", "summary": "Oedipus keeps investigating Laius’s death, but the Corinthian encounter never turns that investigation into the canonical search for his origins. The already summoned murder witness remains a lead. The best supported continuation pursues that crime without completing the original chain of identity revelations.", "supportedBy": [ "messenger-lead", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "messenger-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The link through Corinth is missing.", "because": "Removing the full encounter removes both the adoption disclosure and the report connecting the infant to the Shepherd. Oedipus retains his existing belief about Polybus.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-messenger", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-polybus", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "messenger-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The parentage inquiry does not take over.", "because": "The persistence decision requires accepted adoption and the handover report. Neither is acquired, so its rule cannot enable the final parentage testimony or recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "messenger-lead", "section": "projection", "title": "The murder inquiry still has a witness to question.", "because": "Oedipus is still investigating and remembers the crossroads killing. In the preserved crossroads scene he has already asked Jocasta to summon Laius’s surviving bondsman, before the Corinthian encounter.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-memory" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The search continues along the murder lead.", "because": "Pursuing an already requested witness preserves Oedipus’s active goal and available information. It does not grant the missing adoption or handover evidence, so no alternative complete identity disclosure is inserted.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-lead" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "What makes a fact become a fact about oneself?", "structuralPremise": "Removing one encounter preserves the murder inquiry but cuts the evidence bridge into the parentage sequence.", "reading": "The facts of killing and birth remain in the world. Their connection for a particular person depends on an encounter that joins two investigations. The local bridge is contingent even though the past it would reveal is fixed.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "messenger-cut", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The whole Corinthian encounter and its three reports.", "Accepted adoption, the handover lead and the parentage-persistence decision." ], "preservedSummary": [ "The initial four events, including the crossroads memory.", "The original murder investigation and its already requested witness.", "The killing, marriage and the prior belief about Polybus." ], "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review", "method": "Checked against pinned Storr passages and the complete joint replay; authored interpretation, not independent literary peer review. Automated support assertions and metrics are checked on every build.", "sourceRefs": [ "p-adoption", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-memory", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] } } ], "canonicalMetrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": true, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": true, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 22, "value": 0, "edits": [], "retainedNodes": 9, "retainedEdges": 13 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 22, "value": 0 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 1, "denominator": 7, "value": 0.14285714285714285, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-accuse", "retainsTargets": true }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-messenger", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-persist", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-testimony", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-accuse", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist", "rule-testimony" ], "singletonCuts": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist", "rule-testimony" ], "minimumSize": 1, "minimumSets": [ [ "rule-oracle" ], [ "rule-investigate" ], [ "rule-crossroads" ], [ "rule-messenger" ], [ "rule-persist" ], [ "rule-testimony" ] ], "alreadyCut": false }, "changedEdges": [] }, "results": [ { "key": "delay-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd" ], "basisId": "delay-shepherd", "run": { "id": "variant", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-variant-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-denial", "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-tiresias" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-denial", "a-accused" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-tiresias" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-messenger" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-persist" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-wait" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-wait" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [ "e-wait" ], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "waiting", "canonical": false, "variant": true }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "canonical": false, "variant": true } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-wait", "label": "Investigation remains awaiting the final testimony", "rule": "rule-wait", "at": "t8" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-wait", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "information:a-handover-report", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-wait", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 13, "denominator": 25, "value": 0.52, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-wait" ], "retainedNodes": 6, "retainedEdges": 6 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 13, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.5909090909090909 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 6, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-accuse", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-messenger", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-persist", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-accuse", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [ { "reasonId": "delay-delivery", "ruleId": "rule-testimony", "eventId": "e-testimony", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "requiredInformation": [], "selectedOption": null, "stateBefore": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "stateAfter": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertionsBefore": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "assertionsAfter": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ] }, { "reasonId": "delay-return", "ruleId": "rule-recognize", "eventId": "e-recognition", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "requiredInformation": [ "a-parentage-report", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": "opt-recognize", "stateBefore": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "stateAfter": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertionsBefore": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "assertionsAfter": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ] }, { "reasonId": "delay-catastrophe", "ruleId": "rule-report", "eventId": "e-report", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "requiredInformation": [], "selectedOption": null, "stateBefore": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "stateAfter": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertionsBefore": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "assertionsAfter": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ] } ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The tragedy is delayed, not defeated.", "summary": "Oedipus misses the original moment of recognition. His pursuit and the final witness remain, so the most supported continuation brings recognition back later. The catastrophic sequence remains plausible; Jocasta’s earlier realization has already put her at risk.", "supportedBy": [ "delay-return", "delay-catastrophe" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "delay-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The last identifying answer arrives later.", "because": "Moving the only final parentage transfer beyond the comparison window leaves testimony false and the parentage report undelivered.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "unscheduled" } ] }, { "id": "delay-recognition", "section": "engine", "title": "Recognition and its reporting branch do not fire on schedule.", "because": "The recognition rule needs both persistence and the final testimony. With that conjunction false, recognition does not fire; the report then lacks its recognized input.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "delay-pressure", "section": "engine", "title": "The search still has a destination.", "because": "Waiting is selected because testimony is absent, while the accepted adoption account, handover report and the Shepherd’s memory all survive. Jocasta has already reached her own inference.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-recognition" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "delay-delivery", "section": "projection", "title": "The witness supplies the missing answer later.", "because": "The selected condition defers delivery to t11; it does not erase the witness or his access to the remembered handover. Continuing the scheduled transfer is the smallest extension of this state.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-pressure" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-testimony" } ], "applyRule": "rule-testimony" }, { "id": "delay-return", "section": "projection", "title": "Recognition becomes possible again.", "because": "The delivered parentage report now joins accepted adoption and the crossroads memory. Every information and decision requirement of the original recognition rule is satisfied.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-delivery" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true } ], "applyRule": "rule-recognize" }, { "id": "delay-catastrophe", "section": "projection", "title": "The tragic mechanism survives.", "because": "With recognition restored and Jocasta already departed, the original reporting branch is supported again in this continuation. This reuses a modeled sequence; it does not make recognition a universal cause of suicide or date Jocasta’s death.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-return" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "recognized", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-catastrophe" } ], "applyRule": "rule-report" } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Was the timing necessary—or the mechanism?", "structuralPremise": "The original window loses both target events, but the same information gates pass again in the continuation.", "reading": "The canonical timing is contingent on one answer. The surviving witness and Oedipus’s persistence make the mechanism harder to escape than its timetable. That distinction concerns this supported continuation, not a proof that every possible future ends alike.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "delay-recognition", "delay-catastrophe" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "Final parentage evidence arrives later.", "Public recognition and the supported reporting sequence move beyond their original checkpoints." ], "preservedSummary": [ "The first six modeled events and the historical killing and marriage.", "Oedipus’s pursuit, adoption belief, murder memory and surviving witness.", "Jocasta’s earlier inference and departure." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-intervention", "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-catastrophe" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": null, "interactionMeaning": null }, { "key": "no-messenger", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger" ], "basisId": "no-messenger", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-denial", "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-tiresias" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-denial", "a-accused" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-tiresias" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony" ], "retainedNodes": 4, "retainedEdges": 3 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.6818181818181818 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 4, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-accuse", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-accuse", "rule-crossroads" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The murder inquiry loses its route into parentage.", "summary": "Oedipus keeps investigating Laius’s death, but the Corinthian encounter never turns that investigation into the canonical search for his origins. The already summoned murder witness remains a lead. The best supported continuation pursues that crime without completing the original chain of identity revelations.", "supportedBy": [ "messenger-lead", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "messenger-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The link through Corinth is missing.", "because": "Removing the full encounter removes both the adoption disclosure and the report connecting the infant to the Shepherd. Oedipus retains his existing belief about Polybus.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-messenger", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-polybus", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "messenger-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The parentage inquiry does not take over.", "because": "The persistence decision requires accepted adoption and the handover report. Neither is acquired, so its rule cannot enable the final parentage testimony or recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "messenger-lead", "section": "projection", "title": "The murder inquiry still has a witness to question.", "because": "Oedipus is still investigating and remembers the crossroads killing. In the preserved crossroads scene he has already asked Jocasta to summon Laius’s surviving bondsman, before the Corinthian encounter.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-memory" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The search continues along the murder lead.", "because": "Pursuing an already requested witness preserves Oedipus’s active goal and available information. It does not grant the missing adoption or handover evidence, so no alternative complete identity disclosure is inserted.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-lead" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "What makes a fact become a fact about oneself?", "structuralPremise": "Removing one encounter preserves the murder inquiry but cuts the evidence bridge into the parentage sequence.", "reading": "The facts of killing and birth remain in the world. Their connection for a particular person depends on an encounter that joins two investigations. The local bridge is contingent even though the past it would reveal is fixed.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "messenger-cut", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The whole Corinthian encounter and its three reports.", "Accepted adoption, the handover lead and the parentage-persistence decision." ], "preservedSummary": [ "The initial four events, including the crossroads memory.", "The original murder investigation and its already requested witness.", "The killing, marriage and the prior belief about Polybus." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-adoption", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-memory", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": null, "interactionMeaning": null }, { "key": "omit-accusation", "selectedIds": [ "omit-accusation" ], "basisId": "omit-accusation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "complete", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-messenger" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-persist" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-testimony" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "testimony", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-parentage-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-shepherd" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-recognition" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-parentage-report", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": "opt-recognize", "effects": [ { "variable": "recognized", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-report" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "report-supported", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "value": true }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "tragic", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "true" } }, "issues": [] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-tiresias" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused" ], "assertionsAdded": [], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": true, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": true, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": [ "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 8, "retainedEdges": 12 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.09090909090909091 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 6, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-messenger", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-persist", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-testimony", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist", "rule-testimony" ], "singletonCuts": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist", "rule-testimony" ], "minimumSize": 1, "minimumSets": [ [ "rule-oracle" ], [ "rule-investigate" ], [ "rule-crossroads" ], [ "rule-messenger" ], [ "rule-persist" ], [ "rule-testimony" ] ], "alreadyCut": false }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The tragedy survives without the accusation.", "summary": "Oedipus still reaches the same recognition and catastrophe report. The crossroads memory, adoption account and Shepherd’s testimony supply the evidence he eventually accepts; the rejected accusation is not a necessary input.", "supportedBy": [ "seer-recognition", "seer-outcome" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "seer-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The accusation and its rejection disappear.", "because": "Suppressing this bundled episode removes the received accusation and the denial it provokes, without changing Oedipus’s prior commitment to investigate.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-tiresias", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-accused", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true } ] }, { "id": "seer-route", "section": "engine", "title": "The evidence route remains intact.", "because": "The crossroads exchange is enabled by the investigation, not by Tiresias’s speech. The later Messenger and Shepherd episodes therefore still occur.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "seer-input" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-crossroads", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-messenger", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-testimony", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired" } ] }, { "id": "seer-recognition", "section": "engine", "title": "Oedipus reaches the same recognition.", "because": "The rule requires remembered killing, accepted adoption and reported parentage. All three arrive even without the accusation.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "seer-route" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "fired" } ] }, { "id": "seer-outcome", "section": "engine", "title": "The original catastrophe is still reported.", "because": "Completed recognition and Jocasta’s departure satisfy the reporting rule, so both modeled harm dimensions are established in the replay.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "seer-recognition" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "jocasta-dead", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "oedipus-blind", "value": true } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Is saying the truth the same as making it knowable?", "structuralPremise": "Removing the accusation preserves every dependency route to the two target events.", "reading": "A true charge can be dramatically central without being a necessary cause of recognition. Here agency changes when evidence becomes acceptable to Oedipus, not merely when someone speaks the truth.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "seer-route", "seer-outcome" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "Tiresias’s accusation and Oedipus’s immediate denial." ], "preservedSummary": [ "All eight other canonical events.", "Every modeled dependency route into recognition and the catastrophe report.", "The same past, recognition and reported harms." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": null, "interactionMeaning": null }, { "key": "silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "silence-shepherd" ], "basisId": "silence-shepherd", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-denial", "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-tiresias" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-denial", "a-accused" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-tiresias" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-messenger" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-persist" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-wait" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-wait" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [ "e-wait" ], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "waiting", "canonical": false, "variant": true }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "canonical": false, "variant": true } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-wait", "label": "Investigation remains awaiting the final testimony", "rule": "rule-wait", "at": "t8" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-wait", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "information:a-handover-report", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-wait", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 13, "denominator": 25, "value": 0.52, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-wait" ], "retainedNodes": 6, "retainedEdges": 6 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 13, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.5909090909090909 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 6, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-accuse", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-messenger", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-persist", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-accuse", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "Recognition becomes avoidable. The harm is not erased.", "summary": "The search continues without the corroboration that completes Oedipus’s recognition. Holding the final answer back breaks that route for as long as the condition is maintained. Jocasta has already inferred the truth, so this is no rescue for the whole household.", "supportedBy": [ "silence-pressure", "silence-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "silence-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The identifying channel stays closed.", "because": "The held condition disables the final testimony rule and its parentage transfer. The Shepherd’s existing memory is preserved; Oedipus never receives its identifying content.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "silence-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The final recognition gate stays closed.", "because": "Persistence alone cannot satisfy the recognition conjunction. Waiting replaces recognition, and the canonical reporting branch does not fire.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "silence-pressure", "section": "projection", "title": "Oedipus still pursues the evidence.", "because": "The intervention changes access to an answer, not his accepted adoption evidence or his resolve to learn his origins. The text supports continued pressure on this same witness.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-plea" } ] }, { "id": "silence-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The inquiry persists without completed self-recognition.", "because": "Restoring the final answer would reverse the selected condition. Keeping the search open uses the existing goal and witness without inventing a substitute disclosure. Jocasta’s prior inference and the historical harms remain.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-pressure" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "recognized", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "present": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-testimony" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Can withholding knowledge prevent responsibility?", "structuralPremise": "A single held disclosure cuts the modeled recognition pathway, while Jocasta’s inference and the historical harms survive.", "reading": "Recognition is contingent on access to evidence; the acts being recognized are not. Blocking self-knowledge interrupts this public reckoning without undoing what Oedipus has done or what Jocasta already understands.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "silence-cut", "silence-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The final parentage disclosure is persistently blocked.", "The recognition and catastrophe-report routes lose a required input." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Investigation, accepted adoption and the witness’s memory.", "Jocasta’s separate inference and departure.", "The killing and marriage before the play." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": null, "interactionMeaning": null }, { "key": "stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Is avoiding revelation the same as escaping tragedy?", "structuralPremise": "Disabling the opening action cuts both target pathways with one intervention; the reported civic demand is retained.", "reading": "The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The investigation action and its downstream discoveries.", "Recognition and the canonical catastrophe report do not occur in the modeled sequence." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon’s report and the city’s demand for an answer.", "The historical killing and marriage.", "No replacement investigator, cure or new punishment is introduced." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-oracle", "p-quest" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": null, "interactionMeaning": null }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+omit-accusation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "omit-accusation" ], "basisId": "delay-shepherd", "run": { "id": "variant", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-variant-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-messenger" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-persist" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-wait" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-wait" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-tiresias", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [ "e-wait" ], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "waiting", "canonical": false, "variant": true }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "canonical": false, "variant": true } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-wait", "label": "Investigation remains awaiting the final testimony", "rule": "rule-wait", "at": "t8" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-wait", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "information:a-handover-report", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-wait", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 25, "value": 0.6, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "retainedNodes": 5, "retainedEdges": 5 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.6818181818181818 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 5, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-messenger", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-persist", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [ { "reasonId": "delay-delivery", "ruleId": "rule-testimony", "eventId": "e-testimony", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "requiredInformation": [], "selectedOption": null, "stateBefore": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "stateAfter": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertionsBefore": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "assertionsAfter": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ] }, { "reasonId": "delay-return", "ruleId": "rule-recognize", "eventId": "e-recognition", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "requiredInformation": [ "a-parentage-report", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": "opt-recognize", "stateBefore": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "stateAfter": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertionsBefore": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "assertionsAfter": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ] }, { "reasonId": "delay-catastrophe", "ruleId": "rule-report", "eventId": "e-report", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "requiredInformation": [], "selectedOption": null, "stateBefore": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "stateAfter": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertionsBefore": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "assertionsAfter": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ] } ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The tragedy is delayed, not defeated.", "summary": "Oedipus misses the original moment of recognition. His pursuit and the final witness remain, so the most supported continuation brings recognition back later. The catastrophic sequence remains plausible; Jocasta’s earlier realization has already put her at risk.", "supportedBy": [ "delay-return", "delay-catastrophe" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-delay-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Delay the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final answer moves from t7 to t11; the original comparison ends at t10. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "delay-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The last identifying answer arrives later.", "because": "Moving the only final parentage transfer beyond the comparison window leaves testimony false and the parentage report undelivered.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "unscheduled" } ] }, { "id": "delay-recognition", "section": "engine", "title": "Recognition and its reporting branch do not fire on schedule.", "because": "The recognition rule needs both persistence and the final testimony. With that conjunction false, recognition does not fire; the report then lacks its recognized input.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "delay-pressure", "section": "engine", "title": "The search still has a destination.", "because": "Waiting is selected because testimony is absent, while the accepted adoption account, handover report and the Shepherd’s memory all survive. Jocasta has already reached her own inference.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-recognition" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "delay-delivery", "section": "projection", "title": "The witness supplies the missing answer later.", "because": "The selected condition defers delivery to t11; it does not erase the witness or his access to the remembered handover. Continuing the scheduled transfer is the smallest extension of this state.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-pressure" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-testimony" } ], "applyRule": "rule-testimony" }, { "id": "delay-return", "section": "projection", "title": "Recognition becomes possible again.", "because": "The delivered parentage report now joins accepted adoption and the crossroads memory. Every information and decision requirement of the original recognition rule is satisfied.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-delivery" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true } ], "applyRule": "rule-recognize" }, { "id": "delay-catastrophe", "section": "projection", "title": "The tragic mechanism survives.", "because": "With recognition restored and Jocasta already departed, the original reporting branch is supported again in this continuation. This reuses a modeled sequence; it does not make recognition a universal cause of suicide or date Jocasta’s death.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "delay-return" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "recognized", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-catastrophe" } ], "applyRule": "rule-report" } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "15 joint edits versus 15 summed single-change edits; 0 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "The joint edit set equals the disjoint union of the single-change edit sets. Their structural effects add under the stated event-and-edge definition. The canonical timing is contingent on one answer. The surviving witness and Oedipus’s persistence make the mechanism harder to escape than its timetable. That distinction concerns this supported continuation, not a proof that every possible future ends alike.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "delay-recognition", "delay-catastrophe" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The final answer moves from t7 to t11; the original comparison ends at t10.", "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "4 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 1 alternative modeled event occurs." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-intervention", "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-catastrophe", "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Independent", "extra": [], "cancelled": [], "overlap": [], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 15, "combinedEdits": 15, "nonAdditivity": 0, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "delay-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "The joint edit set equals the disjoint union of the single-change edit sets. Their structural effects add under the stated event-and-edge definition." }, { "key": "no-messenger+omit-accusation", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger", "omit-accusation" ], "basisId": "no-messenger", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-tiresias", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 17, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.7727272727272727, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 3, "retainedEdges": 2 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 17, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.7727272727272727 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 3, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-crossroads" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The murder inquiry loses its route into parentage.", "summary": "Oedipus keeps investigating Laius’s death, but the Corinthian encounter never turns that investigation into the canonical search for his origins. The already summoned murder witness remains a lead. The best supported continuation pursues that crime without completing the original chain of identity revelations.", "supportedBy": [ "messenger-lead", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-no-messenger", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "because": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The link through Corinth is missing.", "because": "Removing the full encounter removes both the adoption disclosure and the report connecting the infant to the Shepherd. Oedipus retains his existing belief about Polybus.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-messenger", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-polybus", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "messenger-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The parentage inquiry does not take over.", "because": "The persistence decision requires accepted adoption and the handover report. Neither is acquired, so its rule cannot enable the final parentage testimony or recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "messenger-lead", "section": "projection", "title": "The murder inquiry still has a witness to question.", "because": "Oedipus is still investigating and remembers the crossroads killing. In the preserved crossroads scene he has already asked Jocasta to summon Laius’s surviving bondsman, before the Corinthian encounter.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-memory" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The search continues along the murder lead.", "because": "Pursuing an already requested witness preserves Oedipus’s active goal and available information. It does not grant the missing adoption or handover evidence, so no alternative complete identity disclosure is inserted.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-lead" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "17 joint edits versus 17 summed single-change edits; 0 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "The joint edit set equals the disjoint union of the single-change edit sets. Their structural effects add under the stated event-and-edge definition. The facts of killing and birth remain in the world. Their connection for a particular person depends on an encounter that joins two investigations. The local bridge is contingent even though the past it would reveal is fixed.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "messenger-cut", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "6 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Independent", "extra": [], "cancelled": [], "overlap": [], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "summedEdits": 17, "combinedEdits": 17, "nonAdditivity": 0, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "no-messenger", "distance": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": 15, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "The joint edit set equals the disjoint union of the single-change edit sets. Their structural effects add under the stated event-and-edge definition." }, { "key": "no-messenger+silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger", "silence-shepherd" ], "basisId": "no-messenger", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-denial", "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-tiresias" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-denial", "a-accused" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-tiresias" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony" ], "retainedNodes": 4, "retainedEdges": 3 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.6818181818181818 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 4, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-accuse", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-accuse", "rule-crossroads" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The murder inquiry loses its route into parentage.", "summary": "Oedipus keeps investigating Laius’s death, but the Corinthian encounter never turns that investigation into the canonical search for his origins. The already summoned murder witness remains a lead. The best supported continuation pursues that crime without completing the original chain of identity revelations.", "supportedBy": [ "messenger-lead", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-silence-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-no-messenger", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "because": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The link through Corinth is missing.", "because": "Removing the full encounter removes both the adoption disclosure and the report connecting the infant to the Shepherd. Oedipus retains his existing belief about Polybus.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-messenger", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-polybus", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "messenger-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The parentage inquiry does not take over.", "because": "The persistence decision requires accepted adoption and the handover report. Neither is acquired, so its rule cannot enable the final parentage testimony or recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "messenger-lead", "section": "projection", "title": "The murder inquiry still has a witness to question.", "because": "Oedipus is still investigating and remembers the crossroads killing. In the preserved crossroads scene he has already asked Jocasta to summon Laius’s surviving bondsman, before the Corinthian encounter.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-memory" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The search continues along the murder lead.", "because": "Pursuing an already requested witness preserves Oedipus’s active goal and available information. It does not grant the missing adoption or handover evidence, so no alternative complete identity disclosure is inserted.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-lead" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "15 joint edits versus 28 summed single-change edits; 10 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event. The facts of killing and birth remain in the world. Their connection for a particular person depends on an encounter that joins two investigations. The local bridge is contingent even though the past it would reveal is fixed.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "messenger-cut", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "5 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model", "p-adoption", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-memory", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Masking", "extra": [], "cancelled": [ "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "node:e-wait" ], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 28, "combinedEdits": 15, "nonAdditivity": -13, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "no-messenger", "distance": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": 15, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "silence-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event." }, { "key": "no-messenger+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger", "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-stop-investigation", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "because": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-no-messenger", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "because": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Does adding causes make the catastrophe more necessary?", "structuralPremise": "21 joint edits versus 36 summed single-change edits; 15 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "At least two selected changes remove some of the same structural units. The joint replay produces no extra edits beyond their union: increasing the number of changes does not increase their effect proportionally. The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "8 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-oracle", "p-quest", "p-adoption", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-memory", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Redundant", "extra": [], "cancelled": [], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "summedEdits": 36, "combinedEdits": 21, "nonAdditivity": -15, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "no-messenger", "distance": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": 15, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "distance": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": 21, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "At least two selected changes remove some of the same structural units. The joint replay produces no extra edits beyond their union: increasing the number of changes does not increase their effect proportionally." }, { "key": "omit-accusation+silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd" ], "basisId": "silence-shepherd", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-messenger" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-persist" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-wait" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-wait" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-tiresias", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [ "e-wait" ], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "waiting", "canonical": false, "variant": true }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "canonical": false, "variant": true } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-wait", "label": "Investigation remains awaiting the final testimony", "rule": "rule-wait", "at": "t8" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-wait", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "information:a-handover-report", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-wait", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-wait", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 25, "value": 0.6, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "retainedNodes": 5, "retainedEdges": 5 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 15, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.6818181818181818 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 5, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-messenger", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-persist", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "Recognition becomes avoidable. The harm is not erased.", "summary": "The search continues without the corroboration that completes Oedipus’s recognition. Holding the final answer back breaks that route for as long as the condition is maintained. Jocasta has already inferred the truth, so this is no rescue for the whole household.", "supportedBy": [ "silence-pressure", "silence-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-silence-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "silence-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The identifying channel stays closed.", "because": "The held condition disables the final testimony rule and its parentage transfer. The Shepherd’s existing memory is preserved; Oedipus never receives its identifying content.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "testimony", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-parentage-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "silence-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The final recognition gate stays closed.", "because": "Persistence alone cannot satisfy the recognition conjunction. Waiting replaces recognition, and the canonical reporting branch does not fire.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "silence-pressure", "section": "projection", "title": "Oedipus still pursues the evidence.", "because": "The intervention changes access to an answer, not his accepted adoption evidence or his resolve to learn his origins. The text supports continued pressure on this same witness.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-plea" } ] }, { "id": "silence-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The inquiry persists without completed self-recognition.", "because": "Restoring the final answer would reverse the selected condition. Keeping the search open uses the existing goal and witness without inventing a substitute disclosure. Jocasta’s prior inference and the historical harms remain.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "silence-pressure" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "recognized", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "present": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-testimony" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "15 joint edits versus 15 summed single-change edits; 0 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "The joint edit set equals the disjoint union of the single-change edit sets. Their structural effects add under the stated event-and-edge definition. Recognition is contingent on access to evidence; the acts being recognized are not. Blocking self-knowledge interrupts this public reckoning without undoing what Oedipus has done or what Jocasta already understands.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "silence-cut", "silence-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "4 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 1 alternative modeled event occurs." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Independent", "extra": [], "cancelled": [], "overlap": [], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 15, "combinedEdits": 15, "nonAdditivity": 0, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "silence-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "The joint edit set equals the disjoint union of the single-change edit sets. Their structural effects add under the stated event-and-edge definition." }, { "key": "omit-accusation+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "omit-accusation", "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-stop-investigation", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "because": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Does adding causes make the catastrophe more necessary?", "structuralPremise": "21 joint edits versus 23 summed single-change edits; 2 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "At least two selected changes remove some of the same structural units. The joint replay produces no extra edits beyond their union: increasing the number of changes does not increase their effect proportionally. The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "8 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe", "p-oracle", "p-quest" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Redundant", "extra": [], "cancelled": [], "overlap": [ "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "node:e-tiresias" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "summedEdits": 23, "combinedEdits": 21, "nonAdditivity": -2, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "distance": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": 21, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "At least two selected changes remove some of the same structural units. The joint replay produces no extra edits beyond their union: increasing the number of changes does not increase their effect proportionally." }, { "key": "silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-silence-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-stop-investigation", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "because": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "21 joint edits versus 34 summed single-change edits; 10 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event. The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "8 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model", "p-oracle", "p-quest" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Masking", "extra": [], "cancelled": [ "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "node:e-wait" ], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 34, "combinedEdits": 21, "nonAdditivity": -13, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "silence-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "distance": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": 21, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event." }, { "key": "no-messenger+omit-accusation+silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger", "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd" ], "basisId": "no-messenger", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-tiresias", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] } ] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 17, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.7727272727272727, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 3, "retainedEdges": 2 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 17, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.7727272727272727 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 3, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-investigate", "retainsTargets": false }, { "rule": "rule-crossroads", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-crossroads" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The murder inquiry loses its route into parentage.", "summary": "Oedipus keeps investigating Laius’s death, but the Corinthian encounter never turns that investigation into the canonical search for his origins. The already summoned murder witness remains a lead. The best supported continuation pursues that crime without completing the original chain of identity revelations.", "supportedBy": [ "messenger-lead", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-silence-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-no-messenger", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "because": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The link through Corinth is missing.", "because": "Removing the full encounter removes both the adoption disclosure and the report connecting the infant to the Shepherd. Oedipus retains his existing belief about Polybus.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-messenger", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-polybus", "present": true } ] }, { "id": "messenger-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The parentage inquiry does not take over.", "because": "The persistence decision requires accepted adoption and the handover report. Neither is acquired, so its rule cannot enable the final parentage testimony or recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "persisting", "value": false }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "messenger-lead", "section": "projection", "title": "The murder inquiry still has a witness to question.", "because": "Oedipus is still investigating and remembers the crossroads killing. In the preserved crossroads scene he has already asked Jocasta to summon Laius’s surviving bondsman, before the Corinthian encounter.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-cut" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-memory", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-memory" } ] }, { "id": "messenger-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "The search continues along the murder lead.", "because": "Pursuing an already requested witness preserves Oedipus’s active goal and available information. It does not grant the missing adoption or handover evidence, so no alternative complete identity disclosure is inserted.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "messenger-lead" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "present": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-handover-report", "present": false }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-summon" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "17 joint edits versus 30 summed single-change edits; 10 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event. The facts of killing and birth remain in the world. Their connection for a particular person depends on an encounter that joins two investigations. The local bridge is contingent even though the past it would reveal is fixed.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "messenger-cut", "messenger-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "6 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Masking", "extra": [], "cancelled": [ "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "node:e-wait" ], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 30, "combinedEdits": 17, "nonAdditivity": -13, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "no-messenger", "distance": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": 15, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "silence-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event." }, { "key": "no-messenger+omit-accusation+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger", "omit-accusation", "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-stop-investigation", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "because": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-no-messenger", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "because": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Does adding causes make the catastrophe more necessary?", "structuralPremise": "21 joint edits versus 38 summed single-change edits; 17 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "At least two selected changes remove some of the same structural units. The joint replay produces no extra edits beyond their union: increasing the number of changes does not increase their effect proportionally. The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "8 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe", "p-oracle", "p-quest", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Redundant", "extra": [], "cancelled": [], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "summedEdits": 38, "combinedEdits": 21, "nonAdditivity": -17, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "no-messenger", "distance": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": 15, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "distance": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": 21, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "At least two selected changes remove some of the same structural units. The joint replay produces no extra edits beyond their union: increasing the number of changes does not increase their effect proportionally." }, { "key": "no-messenger+silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger", "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-silence-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-stop-investigation", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "because": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-no-messenger", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "because": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "21 joint edits versus 49 summed single-change edits; 15 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event. The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "8 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-testimony", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model", "p-oracle", "p-quest", "p-adoption", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-memory", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Masking", "extra": [], "cancelled": [ "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "node:e-wait" ], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 49, "combinedEdits": 21, "nonAdditivity": -28, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "no-messenger", "distance": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": 15, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "silence-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "distance": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": 21, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event." }, { "key": "omit-accusation+silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-silence-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-stop-investigation", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "because": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "21 joint edits versus 36 summed single-change edits; 12 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event. The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "8 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model", "p-oracle", "p-quest" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Masking", "extra": [], "cancelled": [ "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "node:e-wait" ], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 36, "combinedEdits": 21, "nonAdditivity": -15, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "silence-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "distance": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": 21, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event." }, { "key": "no-messenger+omit-accusation+silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "no-messenger", "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "basisId": "stop-investigation", "run": { "id": "canonical", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [], "retained": [ "e-oracle" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "investigating", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "persisting", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "id": "rule-persist", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "metrics": { "algorithm": "event-support-v1", "canonical": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "rule": "rule-investigate", "at": "t2" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "rule": "rule-accuse", "at": "t3" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "rule": "rule-crossroads", "at": "t4" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "rule": "rule-messenger", "at": "t5" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "rule": "rule-persist", "at": "t6" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "rule": "rule-testimony", "at": "t7" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "rule": "rule-recognize", "at": "t8" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "rule": "rule-report", "at": "t9" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "variant": { "nodes": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "rule": "rule-oracle", "at": "t1" } ], "edges": [] }, "roots": [ "e-oracle" ], "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "label": "Recognition", "event": "e-recognition", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "label": "Catastrophe report", "event": "e-report", "canonicalReached": true, "reached": false, "paths": [ [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-crossroads", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-report" ], [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ] ], "retainedPaths": [] } ], "distance": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "retainedNodes": 1, "retainedEdges": 0 }, "editLoad": { "numerator": 21, "denominator": 22, "value": 0.9545454545454546 }, "tolerance": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 1, "value": 0, "probes": [ { "rule": "rule-oracle", "retainsTargets": false } ] }, "cut": { "eligibleRules": [ "rule-oracle" ], "singletonCuts": [], "minimumSize": 0, "minimumSets": [ [] ], "alreadyCut": true }, "changedEdges": [ { "id": "e-crossroads>e-messenger", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-messenger", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-crossroads", "guard:event:e-crossroads" ] }, { "id": "e-crossroads>e-recognition", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-memory", "decision-information:a-memory" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-persist", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-messenger", "guard:event:e-messenger", "information:a-adoption-accepted", "information:a-handover-report", "decision-guard:event:e-messenger", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-handover-report" ] }, { "id": "e-messenger>e-recognition", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "information:a-adoption-accepted", "decision-information:a-adoption-accepted" ] }, { "id": "e-oracle>e-quest", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "e-quest", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-oracle", "guard:event:e-oracle", "information:a-oracle", "decision-guard:event:e-oracle", "decision-information:a-oracle" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-recognition", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-report", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "guard:jocasta-departed" ] }, { "id": "e-persist>e-testimony", "source": "e-persist", "target": "e-testimony", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-persist", "guard:persisting" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-crossroads", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-crossroads", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-persist", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-persist", "reasons": [ "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-quest>e-tiresias", "source": "e-quest", "target": "e-tiresias", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-quest", "guard:investigating" ] }, { "id": "e-recognition>e-report", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "e-report", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-recognition", "guard:recognized" ] }, { "id": "e-testimony>e-recognition", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "e-recognition", "reasons": [ "prerequisite:e-testimony", "guard:testimony", "information:a-parentage-report", "decision-guard:testimony", "decision-information:a-parentage-report" ] } ] }, "projection": { "policy": "minimal-change-v1", "witnesses": [], "finalState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [] }, "conclusion": { "title": "The reckoning gives way to a failure of rule.", "summary": "Oedipus does not begin the investigation, so the canonical sequence of discoveries and its catastrophe report never start. The city’s demand for an answer remains unanswered: the most supported continuation is a stalled public duty, not a restored Thebes.", "supportedBy": [ "stop-duty", "stop-consequence" ] }, "reasoning": [ { "id": "selected-omit-accusation", "section": "engine", "title": "Remove Tiresias’s accusation", "because": "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-silence-shepherd", "section": "engine", "title": "Withhold the Shepherd’s testimony", "because": "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-stop-investigation", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent Oedipus’s investigation", "because": "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "selected-no-messenger", "section": "engine", "title": "Prevent the Corinthian encounter", "because": "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation. Its effect is evaluated together with every selected condition.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" } ] }, { "id": "stop-input", "section": "engine", "title": "The report arrives, but the king’s inquiry does not begin.", "because": "The intervention disables the investigation action and its decision option. Receiving the oracle’s demand alone does not create the investigating state.", "support": [ { "kind": "operation" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-quest", "present": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "blocked" } ] }, { "id": "stop-cut", "section": "engine", "title": "The downstream discovery sequence never starts.", "because": "Both the seer episode and the crossroads exchange require investigating. Without that enabling state, neither can start the chain that reaches adoption, parentage and recognition.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-input" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "rule", "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "blocked" }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-recognition", "present": false }, { "kind": "event", "id": "e-report", "present": false } ] }, { "id": "stop-duty", "section": "projection", "title": "The public demand remains unanswered.", "because": "The canonical report called for pursuit of Laius’s killer. Suppressing Oedipus’s response removes no part of that demand and supplies no alternative investigation or cure.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-cut" }, { "kind": "assertion", "id": "a-oracle", "present": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-quest" } ] }, { "id": "stop-consequence", "section": "projection", "title": "A blocked duty replaces the personal revelation.", "because": "While the selected action remains disabled, the smallest continuation preserves this impasse and the prior harms. The oracle’s promise is reported content; no medical or supernatural outcome is inferred from it.", "support": [ { "kind": "prior", "id": "stop-duty" }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "investigating", "value": false }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "kind": "state", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true }, { "kind": "source", "id": "p-oracle" } ] } ], "philosophy": { "question": "Do these conditions matter separately or together?", "structuralPremise": "21 joint edits versus 51 summed single-change edits; 17 shared edits and 0 additional edits.", "reading": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event. The personal catastrophe depends on an act of inquiry. Yet refusing that act also means failing the duty that motivated it. The structural cut changes the form of failure rather than proving that the world has been repaired.", "metricKeys": [ "targets", "distance", "cut", "tolerance" ], "supportedBy": [ "stop-cut", "stop-consequence" ] }, "changedSummary": [ "The accusation-and-rejection episode at t3 does not occur; all its information updates are omitted together.", "The final parentage answer remains withheld throughout this counterfactual, including its continuation.", "Oedipus is prevented from opening the inquiry; this action remains disabled throughout the counterfactual.", "The entire Corinthian Messenger encounter is absent, including all of its information updates; it remains absent in the continuation.", "8 canonical events are absent from the joint replay; 0 alternative modeled events occur." ], "preservedSummary": [ "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "All immutable historical facts and every unselected condition are preserved except for causal consequences of the selected set." ], "review": { "method": "joint replay + source-grounded consequence signature + checked support references", "sourceRefs": [ "p-accusation", "p-memory", "p-adoption", "p-testimony", "p-catastrophe", "p-plea", "p-recognition-model", "p-oracle", "p-quest", "p-handover", "p-polybus-dead", "p-summon" ], "checks": [ "minimal-change", "character-continuity", "knowledge-consistency", "causal-continuity", "world-preservation", "no-miraculous-rescue", "no-arbitrary-catastrophe" ] }, "interaction": { "classification": "Masking", "extra": [], "cancelled": [ "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "node:e-wait" ], "overlap": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias" ], "unionPrediction": [ "edge:e-crossroads>e-messenger", "edge:e-crossroads>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-persist", "edge:e-messenger>e-recognition", "edge:e-messenger>e-wait", "edge:e-oracle>e-quest", "edge:e-persist>e-recognition", "edge:e-persist>e-report", "edge:e-persist>e-testimony", "edge:e-persist>e-wait", "edge:e-quest>e-crossroads", "edge:e-quest>e-persist", "edge:e-quest>e-tiresias", "edge:e-recognition>e-report", "edge:e-testimony>e-recognition", "node:e-crossroads", "node:e-messenger", "node:e-persist", "node:e-quest", "node:e-recognition", "node:e-report", "node:e-testimony", "node:e-tiresias", "node:e-wait" ], "summedEdits": 51, "combinedEdits": 21, "nonAdditivity": -30, "denominator": 22, "additionalPathsRemoved": [ { "target": "recognition", "paths": [] }, { "target": "catastrophe-report", "paths": [] } ], "newlyCriticalRules": [], "alone": [ { "id": "no-messenger", "distance": 0.6818181818181818, "edits": 15, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "omit-accusation", "distance": 0.09090909090909091, "edits": 2, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": true }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": true } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 6, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 8, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "silence-shepherd", "distance": 0.52, "edits": 13, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] }, { "id": "stop-investigation", "distance": 0.9545454545454546, "edits": 21, "targets": [ { "id": "recognition", "reached": false }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "reached": false } ], "paths": [ { "id": "recognition", "retained": 0, "total": 6 }, { "id": "catastrophe-report", "retained": 0, "total": 8 } ] } ] }, "interactionMeaning": "An upstream cut also prevents a downstream alternative branch from becoming enabled. Some added effects of a single change are therefore masked; this does not restore either target event." } ], "conflicts": [ { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger" ], "reason": "Delaying the final answer requires the parentage inquiry to reach the Shepherd. Another selected change prevents that inquiry." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "silence-shepherd" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "Delaying the final answer requires the parentage inquiry to reach the Shepherd. Another selected change prevents that inquiry." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger+omit-accusation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger", "omit-accusation" ], "reason": "Delaying the final answer requires the parentage inquiry to reach the Shepherd. Another selected change prevents that inquiry." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger+silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger", "silence-shepherd" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "Delaying the final answer requires the parentage inquiry to reach the Shepherd. Another selected change prevents that inquiry." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+omit-accusation+silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+omit-accusation+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "omit-accusation", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "Delaying the final answer requires the parentage inquiry to reach the Shepherd. Another selected change prevents that inquiry." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger+omit-accusation+silence-shepherd", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger", "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger+omit-accusation+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger", "omit-accusation", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "Delaying the final answer requires the parentage inquiry to reach the Shepherd. Another selected change prevents that inquiry." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger+silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger", "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+omit-accusation+silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." }, { "key": "delay-shepherd+no-messenger+omit-accusation+silence-shepherd+stop-investigation", "selectedIds": [ "delay-shepherd", "no-messenger", "omit-accusation", "silence-shepherd", "stop-investigation" ], "reason": "The same testimony cannot both arrive later and remain permanently withheld." } ], "census": { "possibleNonemptySets": 31, "validSets": 17, "incompatibleSets": 14, "minimumInterventionSize": 1, "minimalSets": [ [ "delay-shepherd" ], [ "no-messenger" ], [ "silence-shepherd" ], [ "stop-investigation" ] ], "cardinality": [ { "changes": 1, "validSets": 5, "targetsRetained": 1, "projectedTargetsRetained": 2 }, { "changes": 2, "validSets": 7, "targetsRetained": 0, "projectedTargetsRetained": 1 }, { "changes": 3, "validSets": 4, "targetsRetained": 0, "projectedTargetsRetained": 0 }, { "changes": 4, "validSets": 1, "targetsRetained": 0, "projectedTargetsRetained": 0 }, { "changes": 5, "validSets": 0, "targetsRetained": 0, "projectedTargetsRetained": 0 } ] } }, "passages": [ { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 85, 98 ], "anchor": "pg31-L85-L98", "passageHash": "c757f7cf1d581f1a221b5ee6ff735a8dc994f660c77e19abfb8fe10b07282f8b" } }, "text": "DRAMATIS PERSONAE\n\nOedipus.\nThe Priest of Zeus.\nCreon.\nChorus of Theban Elders.\nTeiresias.\nJocasta.\nMessenger.\nHerd of Laius.\nSecond Messenger.\n\nScene: Thebes. Before the Palace of Oedipus.\n\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 184, 193 ], "anchor": "pg31-L184-L193", "passageHash": "91f7cc4ae0c7f997aec9ec616a673f9b7b5f3b34a76e40b939b93d36ea26cf5c" } }, "text": "Him and none other, but I grieve at once\nBoth for the general and myself and you.\nTherefore ye rouse no sluggard from day-dreams.\nMany, my children, are the tears I’ve wept,\nAnd threaded many a maze of weary thought.\nThus pondering one clue of hope I caught,\nAnd tracked it up; I have sent Menoeceus’ son,\nCreon, my consort’s brother, to inquire\nOf Pythian Phoebus at his Delphic shrine,\nHow I might save the State by act or word.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 233, 284 ], "anchor": "pg31-L233-L284", "passageHash": "98b68928190d765f043956c748bb094fa30659b7b4d5a562ff98226b3ea22b9a" } }, "text": "CREON.\nIf thou wouldst hear my message publicly,\nI’ll tell thee straight, or with thee pass within.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nSpeak before all; the burden that I bear\nIs more for these my subjects than myself.\n\n\nCREON.\nLet me report then all the god declared.\nKing Phoebus bids us straitly extirpate\nA fell pollution that infests the land,\nAnd no more harbor an inveterate sore.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat expiation means he? What’s amiss?\n\n\nCREON.\nBanishment, or the shedding blood for blood.\nThis stain of blood makes shipwreck of our state.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhom can he mean, the miscreant thus denounced?\n\n\nCREON.\nBefore thou didst assume the helm of State,\nThe sovereign of this land was Laius.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nI heard as much, but never saw the man.\n\n\nCREON.\nHe fell; and now the god’s command is plain:\nPunish his takers-off, whoe’er they be.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhere are they? Where in the wide world to find\nThe far, faint traces of a bygone crime?\n\n\nCREON.\nIn this land, said the god; “who seeks shall find;\nWho sits with folded hands or sleeps is blind.”\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 302, 314 ], "anchor": "pg31-L302-L314", "passageHash": "9008e130bc70c63128577d7368d8ac13133ae58f46534bca5c53d347ea4ca0e8" } }, "text": "CREON.\nBut one escape, who flying for dear life,\nCould tell of all he saw but one thing sure.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nAnd what was that? One clue might lead us far,\nWith but a spark of hope to guide our quest.\n\n\nCREON.\nRobbers, he told us, not one bandit but\nA troop of knaves, attacked and murdered him.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 337, 351 ], "anchor": "pg31-L337-L351", "passageHash": "557553e716e0ec8ed9462b5ede1550fd22dbab3b03d3716f981560bac10f923d" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nWell, _I_ will start afresh and once again\nMake dark things clear. Right worthy the concern\nOf Phoebus, worthy thine too, for the dead;\nI also, as is meet, will lend my aid\nTo avenge this wrong to Thebes and to the god.\nNot for some far-off kinsman, but myself,\nShall I expel this poison in the blood;\nFor whoso slew that king might have a mind\nTo strike me too with his assassin hand.\nTherefore in righting him I serve myself.\nUp, children, haste ye, quit these altar stairs,\nTake hence your suppliant wands, go summon hither\nThe Theban commons. With the god’s good help\nSuccess is sure; ’tis ruin if we fail.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 675, 731 ], "anchor": "pg31-L675-L731", "passageHash": "42b09ec67a9109ceec39433d5387eddf73128b9422f2e2147a6bc14353b80615" } }, "text": "TEIRESIAS.\nIs it so? Then I charge thee to abide\nBy thine own proclamation; from this day\nSpeak not to these or me. Thou art the man,\nThou the accursed polluter of this land.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nVile slanderer, thou blurtest forth these taunts,\nAnd think’st forsooth as seer to go scot free.\n\n\nTEIRESIAS.\nYea, I am free, strong in the strength of truth.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWho was thy teacher? not methinks thy art.\n\n\nTEIRESIAS.\nThou, goading me against my will to speak.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat speech? repeat it and resolve my doubt.\n\n\nTEIRESIAS.\nDidst miss my sense wouldst thou goad me on?\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nI but half caught thy meaning; say it again.\n\n\nTEIRESIAS.\nI say thou art the murderer of the man\nWhose murderer thou pursuest.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\n Thou shalt rue it\nTwice to repeat so gross a calumny.\n\n\nTEIRESIAS.\nMust I say more to aggravate thy rage?\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nSay all thou wilt; it will be but waste of breath.\n\n\nTEIRESIAS.\nI say thou livest with thy nearest kin\nIn infamy, unwitting in thy shame.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 769, 779 ], "anchor": "pg31-L769-L779", "passageHash": "4aaefec36443accf5c4d4d760f06ec67c569a4120db43fd7afc0aaffa92a8d9f" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nO wealth and empiry and skill by skill\nOutwitted in the battlefield of life,\nWhat spite and envy follow in your train!\nSee, for this crown the State conferred on me.\nA gift, a thing I sought not, for this crown\nThe trusty Creon, my familiar friend,\nHath lain in wait to oust me and suborned\nThis mountebank, this juggling charlatan,\nThis tricksy beggar-priest, for gain alone\nKeen-eyed, but in his proper art stone-blind.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1245, 1264 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1245-L1264", "passageHash": "68179619d38a64ce5bbbbc7c6c2240ebbe59089b99b55629b4da1ec193a0cd2a" } }, "text": "CHORUS.\nCease, princes; lo there comes, and none too soon,\nJocasta from the palace. Who so fit\nAs peacemaker to reconcile your feud?\n[Enter JOCASTA.]\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nMisguided princes, why have ye upraised\nThis wordy wrangle? Are ye not ashamed,\nWhile the whole land lies striken, thus to voice\nYour private injuries? Go in, my lord;\nGo home, my brother, and forebear to make\nA public scandal of a petty grief.\n\n\nCREON.\nMy royal sister, Oedipus, thy lord,\nHath bid me choose (O dread alternative!)\nAn outlaw’s exile or a felon’s death.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1428, 1478 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1428-L1478", "passageHash": "57b098dc5bb011b7076cdc2953e1672b3a3da8c900fde254ddd4a5ca4f52eb23" } }, "text": "JOCASTA.\nThen thou mayest ease thy conscience on that score.\nListen and I’ll convince thee that no man\nHath scot or lot in the prophetic art.\nHere is the proof in brief. An oracle\nOnce came to Laius (I will not say\n’Twas from the Delphic god himself, but from\nHis ministers) declaring he was doomed\nTo perish by the hand of his own son,\nA child that should be born to him by me.\nNow Laius—so at least report affirmed—\nWas murdered on a day by highwaymen,\nNo natives, at a spot where three roads meet.\nAs for the child, it was but three days old,\nWhen Laius, its ankles pierced and pinned\nTogether, gave it to be cast away\nBy others on the trackless mountain side.\nSo then Apollo brought it not to pass\nThe child should be his father’s murderer,\nOr the dread terror find accomplishment,\nAnd Laius be slain by his own son.\nSuch was the prophet’s horoscope. O king,\nRegard it not. Whate’er the god deems fit\nTo search, himself unaided will reveal.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat memories, what wild tumult of the soul\nCame o’er me, lady, as I heard thee speak!\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nWhat mean’st thou? What has shocked and startled thee?\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nMethought I heard thee say that Laius\nWas murdered at the meeting of three roads.\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nSo ran the story that is current still.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhere did this happen? Dost thou know the place?\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nPhocis the land is called; the spot is where\nBranch roads from Delphi and from Daulis meet.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1579, 1640 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1579-L1640", "passageHash": "27ff0400488627829a837daeb306eba9f74521215d2adfea1c11293140921b07" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nAnd thou shalt not be frustrate of thy wish.\nNow my imaginings have gone so far.\nWho has a higher claim that thou to hear\nMy tale of dire adventures? Listen then.\nMy sire was Polybus of Corinth, and\nMy mother Merope, a Dorian;\nAnd I was held the foremost citizen,\nTill a strange thing befell me, strange indeed,\nYet scarce deserving all the heat it stirred.\nA roisterer at some banquet, flown with wine,\nShouted “Thou art not true son of thy sire.”\nIt irked me, but I stomached for the nonce\nThe insult; on the morrow I sought out\nMy mother and my sire and questioned them.\nThey were indignant at the random slur\nCast on my parentage and did their best\nTo comfort me, but still the venomed barb\nRankled, for still the scandal spread and grew.\nSo privily without their leave I went\nTo Delphi, and Apollo sent me back\nBaulked of the knowledge that I came to seek.\nBut other grievous things he prophesied,\nWoes, lamentations, mourning, portents dire;\nTo wit I should defile my mother’s bed\nAnd raise up seed too loathsome to behold,\nAnd slay the father from whose loins I sprang.\nThen, lady,—thou shalt hear the very truth—\nAs I drew near the triple-branching roads,\nA herald met me and a man who sat\nIn a car drawn by colts—as in thy tale—\nThe man in front and the old man himself\nThreatened to thrust me rudely from the path,\nThen jostled by the charioteer in wrath\nI struck him, and the old man, seeing this,\nWatched till I passed and from his car brought down\nFull on my head the double-pointed goad.\n Yet was I quits with him and more; one stroke\nOf my good staff sufficed to fling him clean\nOut of the chariot seat and laid him prone.\nAnd so I slew them every one. But if\nBetwixt this stranger there was aught in common\nWith Laius, who more miserable than I,\nWhat mortal could you find more god-abhorred?\nWretch whom no sojourner, no citizen\nMay harbor or address, whom all are bound\nTo harry from their homes. And this same curse\nWas laid on me, and laid by none but me.\nYea with these hands all gory I pollute\nThe bed of him I slew. Say, am I vile?\nAm I not utterly unclean, a wretch\nDoomed to be banished, and in banishment\nForgo the sight of all my dearest ones,\nAnd never tread again my native earth;\nOr else to wed my mother and slay my sire,\nPolybus, who begat me and upreared?\nIf one should say, this is the handiwork\nOf some inhuman power, who could blame\nHis judgment? But, ye pure and awful gods,\nForbid, forbid that I should see that day!\nMay I be blotted out from living men\nEre such a plague spot set on me its brand!\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1689, 1697 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1689-L1697", "passageHash": "92a05854cb9e093d65b65f82a32be143cf88116f527098a5a6e8c2593da1a901" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nThou reasonest well. Still I would have thee send\nAnd fetch the bondsman hither. See to it.\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nThat will I straightway. Come, let us within.\nI would do nothing that my lord mislikes.\n[Exeunt OEDIPUS and JOCASTA]\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1830, 1884 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1830-L1884", "passageHash": "720d1494c9756aca8de510f2e0f6a84329e35fb2c9dbc5eab968937187e8d437" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nMy wife, my queen, Jocasta, why hast thou\nSummoned me from my palace?\n\n\nJOCASTA.\n Hear this man,\nAnd as thou hearest judge what has become\nOf all those awe-inspiring oracles.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWho is this man, and what his news for me?\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nHe comes from Corinth and his message this:\nThy father Polybus hath passed away.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat? let me have it, stranger, from thy mouth.\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nIf I must first make plain beyond a doubt\nMy message, know that Polybus is dead.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nBy treachery, or by sickness visited?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nOne touch will send an old man to his rest.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nSo of some malady he died, poor man.\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nYes, having measured the full span of years.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nOut on it, lady! why should one regard\nThe Pythian hearth or birds that scream i’ the air?\nDid they not point at me as doomed to slay\nMy father? but he’s dead and in his grave\nAnd here am I who ne’er unsheathed a sword;\nUnless the longing for his absent son\nKilled him and so _I_ slew him in a sense.\nBut, as they stand, the oracles are dead—\nDust, ashes, nothing, dead as Polybus.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1947, 1953 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1947-L1953", "passageHash": "f9436c88d83c9ab371159164a9d400273e0a66d8cb74de79a453ac99df70834b" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nAye, ’tis no secret. Loxias once foretold\nThat I should mate with mine own mother, and shed\nWith my own hands the blood of my own sire.\nHence Corinth was for many a year to me\nA home distant; and I trove abroad,\nBut missed the sweetest sight, my parents’ face.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2006, 2047 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2006-L2047", "passageHash": "2b991dfb0addab68326a89b5c073ecc22f9b35442a967d2f48449899a8109c3d" } }, "text": "MESSENGER.\nDost thou not know thy fears are baseless all?\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nHow baseless, if I am their very son?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nSince Polybus was naught to thee in blood.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat say’st thou? was not Polybus my sire?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nAs much thy sire as I am, and no more.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nMy sire no more to me than one who is naught?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nSince I begat thee not, no more did he.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat reason had he then to call me son?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nKnow that he took thee from my hands, a gift.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nYet, if no child of his, he loved me well.\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nA childless man till then, he warmed to thee.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2074, 2113 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2074-L2113", "passageHash": "05b73a1e7b7a38da8ce1393387d72cbeef3b22f4e951e918f42f4665ef938706" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nMy savior? from what harm? what ailed me then?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nThose ankle joints are evidence enow.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nAh, why remind me of that ancient sore?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nI loosed the pin that riveted thy feet.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nYes, from my cradle that dread brand I bore.\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nWhence thou deriv’st the name that still is thine.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWho did it? I adjure thee, tell me who\nSay, was it father, mother?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\n I know not.\nThe man from whom I had thee may know more.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat, did another find me, not thyself?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nNot I; another shepherd gave thee me.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2116, 2155 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2116-L2155", "passageHash": "66e7b53ee08e8db4dc63fdc8b479dc115339def3d4cb66a04014b5764229611a" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nWho was he? Would’st thou know again the man?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nHe passed indeed for one of Laius’ house.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nThe king who ruled the country long ago?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nThe same: he was a herdsman of the king.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nAnd is he living still for me to see him?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nHis fellow-countrymen should best know that.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nDoth any bystander among you know\nThe herd he speaks of, or by seeing him\nAfield or in the city? answer straight!\nThe hour hath come to clear this business up.\n\n\nCHORUS.\nMethinks he means none other than the hind\nWhom thou anon wert fain to see; but that\nOur queen Jocasta best of all could tell.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nMadam, dost know the man we sent to fetch?\nIs the same of whom the stranger speaks?\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, "text": "JOCASTA.\nWho is the man? What matter? Let it be.\n’Twere waste of thought to weigh such idle words.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nNo, with such guiding clues I cannot fail\nTo bring to light the secret of my birth.\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nOh, as thou carest for thy life, give o’er\nThis quest. Enough the anguish _I_ endure.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nBe of good cheer; though I be proved the son\nOf a bondwoman, aye, through three descents\nTriply a slave, thy honor is unsmirched.\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nYet humor me, I pray thee; do not this.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nI cannot; I must probe this matter home.\n\n\nJOCASTA.\n’Tis for thy sake I advise thee for the best.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nI grow impatient of this best advice.\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nAh mayst thou ne’er discover who thou art!\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nGo, fetch me here the herd, and leave yon woman\nTo glory in her pride of ancestry.\n\n\nJOCASTA.\nO woe is thee, poor wretch! With that last word\nI leave thee, henceforth silent evermore.\n[Exit JOCASTA]\n\n\nCHORUS.\nWhy, Oedipus, why stung with passionate grief\nHath the queen thus departed? Much I fear\nFrom this dead calm will burst a storm of woes.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nLet the storm burst, my fixed resolve still holds,\nTo learn my lineage, be it ne’er so low.\nIt may be she with all a woman’s pride\nThinks scorn of my base parentage. But I\nWho rank myself as Fortune’s favorite child,\nThe giver of good gifts, shall not be shamed.\nShe is my mother and the changing moons\nMy brethren, and with them I wax and wane.\nThus sprung why should I fear to trace my birth?\nNothing can make me other than I am.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2248, 2346 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2248-L2346", "passageHash": "e5234694068f5aa4d37b5ed7aa5e75e4a0275e02524e612be1820a707b8a769d" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nElders, if I, who never yet before\nHave met the man, may make a guess, methinks\nI see the herdsman who we long have sought;\nHis time-worn aspect matches with the years\nOf yonder aged messenger; besides\nI seem to recognize the men who bring him\nAs servants of my own. But you, perchance,\nHaving in past days known or seen the herd,\nMay better by sure knowledge my surmise.\n\n\nCHORUS.\nI recognize him; one of Laius’ house;\nA simple hind, but true as any man.\n[Enter HERDSMAN.]\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nCorinthian, stranger, I address thee first,\nIs this the man thou meanest!\n\n\nMESSENGER.\n This is he.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nAnd now old man, look up and answer all\nI ask thee. Wast thou once of Laius’ house?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nI was, a thrall, not purchased but home-bred.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat was thy business? how wast thou employed?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nThe best part of my life I tended sheep.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat were the pastures thou didst most frequent?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nCithaeron and the neighboring alps.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\n Then there\nThou must have known yon man, at least by fame?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nYon man? in what way? what man dost thou mean?\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nThe man here, having met him in past times...\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nOff-hand I cannot call him well to mind.\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nNo wonder, master. But I will revive\nHis blunted memories. Sure he can recall\nWhat time together both we drove our flocks,\nHe two, I one, on the Cithaeron range,\nFor three long summers; I his mate from spring\nTill rose Arcturus; then in winter time\nI led mine home, he his to Laius’ folds.\nDid these things happen as I say, or no?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\n’Tis long ago, but all thou say’st is true.\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nWell, thou mast then remember giving me\nA child to rear as my own foster-son?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nWhy dost thou ask this question? What of that?\n\n\nMESSENGER.\nFriend, he that stands before thee was that child.\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nA plague upon thee! Hold thy wanton tongue!\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nDidst give this man the child of whom he asks?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nI did; and would that I had died that day!\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nAnd die thou shalt unless thou tell the truth.\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nBut, if I tell it, I am doubly lost.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nThe knave methinks will still prevaricate.\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nNay, I confessed I gave it long ago.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhence came it? was it thine, or given to thee?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nI had it from another, ’twas not mine.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nFrom whom of these our townsmen, and what house?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nForbear for God’s sake, master, ask no more.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nIf I must question thee again, thou’rt lost.\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nWell then—it was a child of Laius’ house.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nSlave-born or one of Laius’ own race?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nAh me!\nI stand upon the perilous edge of speech.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nAnd I of hearing, but I still must hear.\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nKnow then the child was by repute his own,\nBut she within, thy consort best could tell.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat! she, she gave it thee?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\n ’Tis so, my king.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWith what intent?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\n To make away with it.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat, she its mother.\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\n Fearing a dread weird.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat weird?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\n ’Twas told that he should slay his sire.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWhat didst thou give it then to this old man?\n\n\nHERDSMAN.\nThrough pity, master, for the babe. I thought\nHe’d take it to the country whence he came;\nBut he preserved it for the worst of woes.\nFor if thou art in sooth what this man saith,\nGod pity thee! thou wast to misery born.\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, "text": "OEDIPUS.\nAh me! ah me! all brought to pass, all true!\nO light, may I behold thee nevermore!\nI stand a wretch, in birth, in wedlock cursed,\nA parricide, incestuously, triply cursed!\n[Exit OEDIPUS]\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } }, "text": "SECOND MESSENGER.\nMy tale is quickly told and quickly heard.\nOur sovereign lady queen Jocasta’s dead.\n\n\nCHORUS.\nAlas, poor queen! how came she by her death?\n\n\nSECOND MESSENGER.\nBy her own hand. And all the horror of it,\nNot having seen, yet cannot comprehend.\nNathless, as far as my poor memory serves,\nI will relate the unhappy lady’s woe.\nWhen in her frenzy she had passed inside\nThe vestibule, she hurried straight to win\nThe bridal-chamber, clutching at her hair\nWith both her hands, and, once within the room,\nShe shut the doors behind her with a crash.\n“Laius,” she cried, and called her husband dead\nLong, long ago; her thought was of that child\nBy him begot, the son by whom the sire\nWas murdered and the mother left to breed\nWith her own seed, a monstrous progeny.\nThen she bewailed the marriage bed whereon\nPoor wretch, she had conceived a double brood,\nHusband by husband, children by her child.\nWhat happened after that I cannot tell,\nNor how the end befell, for with a shriek\nBurst on us Oedipus; all eyes were fixed\nOn Oedipus, as up and down he strode,\nNor could we mark her agony to the end.\nFor stalking to and fro “A sword!” he cried,\n“Where is the wife, no wife, the teeming womb\nThat bore a double harvest, me and mine?”\nAnd in his frenzy some supernal power\n(No mortal, surely, none of us who watched him)\nGuided his footsteps; with a terrible shriek,\nAs though one beckoned him, he crashed against\nThe folding doors, and from their staples forced\nThe wrenched bolts and hurled himself within.\nThen we beheld the woman hanging there,\nA running noose entwined about her neck.\nBut when he saw her, with a maddened roar\nHe loosed the cord; and when her wretched corpse\nLay stretched on earth, what followed—O ’twas dread!\nHe tore the golden brooches that upheld\nHer queenly robes, upraised them high and smote\nFull on his eye-balls, uttering words like these:\n“No more shall ye behold such sights of woe,\nDeeds I have suffered and myself have wrought;\nHenceforward quenched in darkness shall ye see\nThose ye should ne’er have seen; now blind to those\nWhom, when I saw, I vainly yearned to know.”\n Such was the burden of his moan, whereto,\nNot once but oft, he struck with his hand uplift\nHis eyes, and at each stroke the ensanguined orbs\nBedewed his beard, not oozing drop by drop,\nBut one black gory downpour, thick as hail.\nSuch evils, issuing from the double source,\nHave whelmed them both, confounding man and wife.\nTill now the storied fortune of this house\nWas fortunate indeed; but from this day\nWoe, lamentation, ruin, death, disgrace,\nAll ills that can be named, all, all are theirs.\n\n\nCHORUS.\nBut hath he still no respite from his pain?\n\n\nSECOND MESSENGER.\nHe cries, “Unbar the doors and let all Thebes\nBehold the slayer of his sire, his mother’s—”\nThat shameful word my lips may not repeat.\nHe vows to fly self-banished from the land,\nNor stay to bring upon his house the curse\nHimself had uttered; but he has no strength\nNor one to guide him, and his torture’s more\nThan man can suffer, as yourselves will see.\nFor lo, the palace portals are unbarred,\nAnd soon ye shall behold a sight so sad\nThat he who must abhorred would pity it.\n[Enter OEDIPUS blinded.]\n" }, { "ref": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2952, 3012 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2952-L3012", "passageHash": "7e8dfa1ea2d98d9435dc5d022ca573f8e504a544763d9c1053e0b36753ca27bf" } }, "text": "CREON.\nThou hast had enough of weeping; pass within.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\n I must obey,\nThough ’tis grievous.\n\n\nCREON.\n Weep not, everything must have its day.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nWell I go, but on conditions.\n\n\nCREON.\n What thy terms for going, say.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nSend me from the land an exile.\n\n\nCREON.\n Ask this of the gods, not me.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nBut I am the gods’ abhorrence.\n\n\nCREON.\n Then they soon will grant thy plea.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nLead me hence, then, I am willing.\n\n\nCREON.\n Come, but let thy children go.\n\n\nOEDIPUS.\nRob me not of these my children!\n\n\nCREON.\n Crave not mastery in all,\nFor the mastery that raised thee was thy bane and wrought thy fall.\n\n\nCHORUS.\nLook ye, countrymen and Thebans, this is Oedipus the great,\nHe who knew the Sphinx’s riddle and was mightiest in our state.\nWho of all our townsmen gazed not on his fame with envious eyes?\nNow, in what a sea of troubles sunk and overwhelmed he lies!\nTherefore wait to see life’s ending ere thou count one mortal blest;\nWait till free from pain and sorrow he has gained his final rest.\n" } ], "versions": { "schema": "0.1.0", "dataset": "v0.1", "ontology": "v0.1", "interpretation": "model-a/v0.1", "engine": "0.1.0", "policy": "policy-v0.1" }, "source": { "id": "storr-pg31-2022", "author": "Sophocles", "translator": "Francis Storr", "title": "Oedipus the King", "container": "The Oedipus Trilogy, Project Gutenberg #31", "edition": "Loeb Library edition, first published 1912; Gutenberg text last updated 2022-03-04", "bibliographyUrl": "https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/31", "sourceUrl": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "retrievedOn": "2026-09-15", "sourceHash": "be8419a2713178f45584eb7421760ff3e5b1a1af4a002cb5c53483ed37041794", "hashAlgorithm": "SHA-256", "rawBytes": 245162, "archive": "source/pg31.txt", "locatorConvention": "1-based physical lines in the pinned UTF-8 text, including blank lines. These are NOT Greek verse numbers. Decode UTF-8 with optional BOM; split CRLF/LF. Preserve all internal whitespace; join selected lines with LF and append one LF for passage hashing.", "passageHashStrategy": "SHA-256 over normalized passage UTF-8 as described above. Whole sourceHash covers exact downloaded bytes including CRLF.", "playBounds": [ 105, 3012 ], "completeness": { "status": "checked", "opening": "Suppliants at the palace; Oedipus enters", "closing": "Chorus final injunction to wait for life’s ending", "nextPlayStartsAt": 3038, "notes": "Includes opening, complete dramatic sequence, exodos and 3 footnotes. No act/scene divisions imposed. Translator ARGUMENT excluded as primary support; dialogue/stage directions used. One acknowledged missing Greek-text passage at note 3 (line 1206); no selected claim depends on it." }, "copyrightStatement": "Project Gutenberg identifies this edition as public domain in the USA; author died c.406 BCE and translator in 1919. Full archive retains Gutenberg notice/license.", "passages": { "cast": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 85, 98 ], "anchor": "pg31-L85-L98", "passageHash": "c757f7cf1d581f1a221b5ee6ff735a8dc994f660c77e19abfb8fe10b07282f8b" } }, "creon": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 184, 193 ], "anchor": "pg31-L184-L193", "passageHash": "91f7cc4ae0c7f997aec9ec616a673f9b7b5f3b34a76e40b939b93d36ea26cf5c" } }, "oracle": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 233, 284 ], "anchor": "pg31-L233-L284", "passageHash": "98b68928190d765f043956c748bb094fa30659b7b4d5a562ff98226b3ea22b9a" } }, "robbers": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 302, 314 ], "anchor": "pg31-L302-L314", "passageHash": "9008e130bc70c63128577d7368d8ac13133ae58f46534bca5c53d347ea4ca0e8" } }, "quest": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 337, 351 ], "anchor": "pg31-L337-L351", "passageHash": "557553e716e0ec8ed9462b5ede1550fd22dbab3b03d3716f981560bac10f923d" } }, "accusation": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 675, 731 ], "anchor": "pg31-L675-L731", "passageHash": "42b09ec67a9109ceec39433d5387eddf73128b9422f2e2147a6bc14353b80615" } }, "plot": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 769, 779 ], "anchor": "pg31-L769-L779", "passageHash": "4aaefec36443accf5c4d4d760f06ec67c569a4120db43fd7afc0aaffa92a8d9f" } }, "kin": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1245, 1264 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1245-L1264", "passageHash": "68179619d38a64ce5bbbbc7c6c2240ebbe59089b99b55629b4da1ec193a0cd2a" } }, "crossroads": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1428, 1478 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1428-L1478", "passageHash": "57b098dc5bb011b7076cdc2953e1672b3a3da8c900fde254ddd4a5ca4f52eb23" } }, "memory": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1579, 1640 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1579-L1640", "passageHash": "27ff0400488627829a837daeb306eba9f74521215d2adfea1c11293140921b07" } }, "summon": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1689, 1697 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1689-L1697", "passageHash": "92a05854cb9e093d65b65f82a32be143cf88116f527098a5a6e8c2593da1a901" } }, "polybus-dead": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1830, 1884 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1830-L1884", "passageHash": "720d1494c9756aca8de510f2e0f6a84329e35fb2c9dbc5eab968937187e8d437" } }, "prophecy": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1947, 1953 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1947-L1953", "passageHash": "f9436c88d83c9ab371159164a9d400273e0a66d8cb74de79a453ac99df70834b" } }, "adoption": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2006, 2047 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2006-L2047", "passageHash": "2b991dfb0addab68326a89b5c073ecc22f9b35442a967d2f48449899a8109c3d" } }, "feet": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2074, 2113 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2074-L2113", "passageHash": "05b73a1e7b7a38da8ce1393387d72cbeef3b22f4e951e918f42f4665ef938706" } }, "handover": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2116, 2155 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2116-L2155", "passageHash": "66e7b53ee08e8db4dc63fdc8b479dc115339def3d4cb66a04014b5764229611a" } }, "plea": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, "shepherd": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2248, 2346 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2248-L2346", "passageHash": "e5234694068f5aa4d37b5ed7aa5e75e4a0275e02524e612be1820a707b8a769d" } }, "testimony": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, "recognition": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, "catastrophe": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } }, "ending": { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2952, 3012 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2952-L3012", "passageHash": "7e8dfa1ea2d98d9435dc5d022ca573f8e504a544763d9c1053e0b36753ca27bf" } } } }, "review": { "metadata": { "id": "oedipus-rex", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "datasetVersion": "v0.1", "ontologyVersion": "v0.1", "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "engineVersion": "0.1.0", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "sourceHash": "be8419a2713178f45584eb7421760ff3e5b1a1af4a002cb5c53483ed37041794" }, "provenance": [ { "id": "p-cast", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 85, 98 ], "anchor": "pg31-L85-L98", "passageHash": "c757f7cf1d581f1a221b5ee6ff735a8dc994f660c77e19abfb8fe10b07282f8b" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-creon", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 184, 193 ], "anchor": "pg31-L184-L193", "passageHash": "91f7cc4ae0c7f997aec9ec616a673f9b7b5f3b34a76e40b939b93d36ea26cf5c" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-oracle", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 233, 284 ], "anchor": "pg31-L233-L284", "passageHash": "98b68928190d765f043956c748bb094fa30659b7b4d5a562ff98226b3ea22b9a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-robbers", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 302, 314 ], "anchor": "pg31-L302-L314", "passageHash": "9008e130bc70c63128577d7368d8ac13133ae58f46534bca5c53d347ea4ca0e8" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-quest", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 337, 351 ], "anchor": "pg31-L337-L351", "passageHash": "557553e716e0ec8ed9462b5ede1550fd22dbab3b03d3716f981560bac10f923d" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-accusation", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 675, 731 ], "anchor": "pg31-L675-L731", "passageHash": "42b09ec67a9109ceec39433d5387eddf73128b9422f2e2147a6bc14353b80615" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-plot", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 769, 779 ], "anchor": "pg31-L769-L779", "passageHash": "4aaefec36443accf5c4d4d760f06ec67c569a4120db43fd7afc0aaffa92a8d9f" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-kin", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1245, 1264 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1245-L1264", "passageHash": "68179619d38a64ce5bbbbc7c6c2240ebbe59089b99b55629b4da1ec193a0cd2a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-crossroads", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1428, 1478 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1428-L1478", "passageHash": "57b098dc5bb011b7076cdc2953e1672b3a3da8c900fde254ddd4a5ca4f52eb23" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-memory", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1579, 1640 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1579-L1640", "passageHash": "27ff0400488627829a837daeb306eba9f74521215d2adfea1c11293140921b07" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-summon", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1689, 1697 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1689-L1697", "passageHash": "92a05854cb9e093d65b65f82a32be143cf88116f527098a5a6e8c2593da1a901" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-polybus-dead", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1830, 1884 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1830-L1884", "passageHash": "720d1494c9756aca8de510f2e0f6a84329e35fb2c9dbc5eab968937187e8d437" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-prophecy", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1947, 1953 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1947-L1953", "passageHash": "f9436c88d83c9ab371159164a9d400273e0a66d8cb74de79a453ac99df70834b" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-adoption", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2006, 2047 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2006-L2047", "passageHash": "2b991dfb0addab68326a89b5c073ecc22f9b35442a967d2f48449899a8109c3d" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-feet", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2074, 2113 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2074-L2113", "passageHash": "05b73a1e7b7a38da8ce1393387d72cbeef3b22f4e951e918f42f4665ef938706" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-handover", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2116, 2155 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2116-L2155", "passageHash": "66e7b53ee08e8db4dc63fdc8b479dc115339def3d4cb66a04014b5764229611a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-plea", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-shepherd", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2248, 2346 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2248-L2346", "passageHash": "e5234694068f5aa4d37b5ed7aa5e75e4a0275e02524e612be1820a707b8a769d" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-testimony", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-recognition", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-catastrophe", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-ending", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2952, 3012 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2952-L3012", "passageHash": "7e8dfa1ea2d98d9435dc5d022ca573f8e504a544763d9c1053e0b36753ca27bf" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-model", "layer": "interpretation", "kind": "INFERRED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-quest", "p-plea", "p-testimony", "p-recognition", "p-catastrophe" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Finite testimony-to-recognition model. Replay rules are editorial assumptions, not universal causal laws." } }, { "id": "p-recognition-model", "layer": "interpretation", "kind": "INFERRED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-plea", "p-recognition", "p-catastrophe" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Oedipus recognition is explicit; Jocasta’s earlier recognition is an interpretation of her plea and later report. Reporting and acceptance remain separate." } }, { "id": "p-initial-model", "layer": "interpretation", "kind": "INFERRED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-memory", "p-testimony" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Initial belief, explicit identity uncertainty and the Shepherd’s memory are reconstructed from later recollection; no earlier omniscience is assumed." } }, { "id": "p-intervention", "layer": "counterfactual", "kind": "COUNTERFACTUAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-testimony", "p-model" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Delay only the final Shepherd information transfer until after the modeled horizon. Refusal is textually attested; duration and continued withholding are a curated perturbation, not a sourced alternate history." } } ], "status": "reviewed-for-experimental-release", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review", "independentPeerReview": false, "reviewedRecordIds": [ "oedipus", "jocasta", "tiresias", "creon", "messenger", "shepherd", "laius", "polybus", "second-messenger", "rel-laius", "rel-jocasta", "rel-marriage", "rel-sibling", "f-parentage", "f-polybus", "f-killer", "f-marriage", "f-oracle", "f-robbers", "f-crossroads", "f-memory", "f-adoption", "f-handover", "f-prophecy", "f-polybus-dead", "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report", "e-wait", "a-polybus", "a-identity-unknown", "a-shepherd-memory", "a-oracle", "a-robbers", "a-accused", "a-denial", "a-crossroads", "a-memory", "a-prophecy", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-parentage-report", "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known", "tr-oracle", "tr-tiresias", "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy", "tr-messenger", "tr-shepherd", "rule-oracle", "rule-investigate", "rule-accuse", "rule-crossroads", "rule-messenger", "rule-persist", "rule-testimony", "rule-recognize", "rule-wait", "rule-report", "decision-investigate", "decision-persist", "decision-response", "outcome-oedipus", "delay-shepherd" ], "limitations": [ "Selected passages checked against pinned edition; not an exhaustive annotation of the play.", "Jocasta recognition timing and all causal rules are interpretations.", "Offstage death has unknown relative order against public recognition; report checkpoint is not death time.", "Catastrophe rule licenses a source-supported report on the baseline sequence. It is not a causal law that recognition necessarily causes suicide. Changed unsupported branches remain unresolved.", "No conclusion that exile actually occurs at the end of Rex.", "Complete-for-scope coverage is restricted to Oedipus identity state in this finite model; no assertion elsewhere means annotation missing." ] }, "ir": { "id": "oedipus-rex", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "datasetVersion": "v0.1", "ontologyVersion": "v0.1", "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "engineVersion": "0.1.0", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "sourceHash": "be8419a2713178f45584eb7421760ff3e5b1a1af4a002cb5c53483ed37041794", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 85, 98 ], "anchor": "pg31-L85-L98", "passageHash": "c757f7cf1d581f1a221b5ee6ff735a8dc994f660c77e19abfb8fe10b07282f8b" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 184, 193 ], "anchor": "pg31-L184-L193", "passageHash": "91f7cc4ae0c7f997aec9ec616a673f9b7b5f3b34a76e40b939b93d36ea26cf5c" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 233, 284 ], "anchor": "pg31-L233-L284", "passageHash": "98b68928190d765f043956c748bb094fa30659b7b4d5a562ff98226b3ea22b9a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 302, 314 ], "anchor": "pg31-L302-L314", "passageHash": "9008e130bc70c63128577d7368d8ac13133ae58f46534bca5c53d347ea4ca0e8" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 337, 351 ], "anchor": "pg31-L337-L351", "passageHash": "557553e716e0ec8ed9462b5ede1550fd22dbab3b03d3716f981560bac10f923d" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 675, 731 ], "anchor": "pg31-L675-L731", "passageHash": "42b09ec67a9109ceec39433d5387eddf73128b9422f2e2147a6bc14353b80615" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 769, 779 ], "anchor": "pg31-L769-L779", "passageHash": "4aaefec36443accf5c4d4d760f06ec67c569a4120db43fd7afc0aaffa92a8d9f" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1245, 1264 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1245-L1264", "passageHash": "68179619d38a64ce5bbbbc7c6c2240ebbe59089b99b55629b4da1ec193a0cd2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1428, 1478 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1428-L1478", "passageHash": "57b098dc5bb011b7076cdc2953e1672b3a3da8c900fde254ddd4a5ca4f52eb23" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1579, 1640 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1579-L1640", "passageHash": "27ff0400488627829a837daeb306eba9f74521215d2adfea1c11293140921b07" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1689, 1697 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1689-L1697", "passageHash": "92a05854cb9e093d65b65f82a32be143cf88116f527098a5a6e8c2593da1a901" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1830, 1884 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1830-L1884", "passageHash": "720d1494c9756aca8de510f2e0f6a84329e35fb2c9dbc5eab968937187e8d437" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1947, 1953 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1947-L1953", "passageHash": "f9436c88d83c9ab371159164a9d400273e0a66d8cb74de79a453ac99df70834b" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2006, 2047 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2006-L2047", "passageHash": "2b991dfb0addab68326a89b5c073ecc22f9b35442a967d2f48449899a8109c3d" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2074, 2113 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2074-L2113", "passageHash": "05b73a1e7b7a38da8ce1393387d72cbeef3b22f4e951e918f42f4665ef938706" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2116, 2155 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2116-L2155", "passageHash": "66e7b53ee08e8db4dc63fdc8b479dc115339def3d4cb66a04014b5764229611a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2248, 2346 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2248-L2346", "passageHash": "e5234694068f5aa4d37b5ed7aa5e75e4a0275e02524e612be1820a707b8a769d" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2952, 3012 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2952-L3012", "passageHash": "7e8dfa1ea2d98d9435dc5d022ca573f8e504a544763d9c1053e0b36753ca27bf" } } ], "provenance": [ { "id": "p-cast", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 85, 98 ], "anchor": "pg31-L85-L98", "passageHash": "c757f7cf1d581f1a221b5ee6ff735a8dc994f660c77e19abfb8fe10b07282f8b" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-creon", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 184, 193 ], "anchor": "pg31-L184-L193", "passageHash": "91f7cc4ae0c7f997aec9ec616a673f9b7b5f3b34a76e40b939b93d36ea26cf5c" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-oracle", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 233, 284 ], "anchor": "pg31-L233-L284", "passageHash": "98b68928190d765f043956c748bb094fa30659b7b4d5a562ff98226b3ea22b9a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-robbers", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 302, 314 ], "anchor": "pg31-L302-L314", "passageHash": "9008e130bc70c63128577d7368d8ac13133ae58f46534bca5c53d347ea4ca0e8" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-quest", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 337, 351 ], "anchor": "pg31-L337-L351", "passageHash": "557553e716e0ec8ed9462b5ede1550fd22dbab3b03d3716f981560bac10f923d" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-accusation", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 675, 731 ], "anchor": "pg31-L675-L731", "passageHash": "42b09ec67a9109ceec39433d5387eddf73128b9422f2e2147a6bc14353b80615" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-plot", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 769, 779 ], "anchor": "pg31-L769-L779", "passageHash": "4aaefec36443accf5c4d4d760f06ec67c569a4120db43fd7afc0aaffa92a8d9f" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-kin", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1245, 1264 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1245-L1264", "passageHash": "68179619d38a64ce5bbbbc7c6c2240ebbe59089b99b55629b4da1ec193a0cd2a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-crossroads", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1428, 1478 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1428-L1478", "passageHash": "57b098dc5bb011b7076cdc2953e1672b3a3da8c900fde254ddd4a5ca4f52eb23" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-memory", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1579, 1640 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1579-L1640", "passageHash": "27ff0400488627829a837daeb306eba9f74521215d2adfea1c11293140921b07" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-summon", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1689, 1697 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1689-L1697", "passageHash": "92a05854cb9e093d65b65f82a32be143cf88116f527098a5a6e8c2593da1a901" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-polybus-dead", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1830, 1884 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1830-L1884", "passageHash": "720d1494c9756aca8de510f2e0f6a84329e35fb2c9dbc5eab968937187e8d437" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-prophecy", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 1947, 1953 ], "anchor": "pg31-L1947-L1953", "passageHash": "f9436c88d83c9ab371159164a9d400273e0a66d8cb74de79a453ac99df70834b" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-adoption", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2006, 2047 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2006-L2047", "passageHash": "2b991dfb0addab68326a89b5c073ecc22f9b35442a967d2f48449899a8109c3d" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-feet", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2074, 2113 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2074-L2113", "passageHash": "05b73a1e7b7a38da8ce1393387d72cbeef3b22f4e951e918f42f4665ef938706" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-handover", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2116, 2155 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2116-L2155", "passageHash": "66e7b53ee08e8db4dc63fdc8b479dc115339def3d4cb66a04014b5764229611a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-plea", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-shepherd", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2248, 2346 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2248-L2346", "passageHash": "e5234694068f5aa4d37b5ed7aa5e75e4a0275e02524e612be1820a707b8a769d" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-testimony", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-recognition", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-catastrophe", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "REPORTED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-ending", "layer": "canonical", "kind": "CANONICAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2952, 3012 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2952-L3012", "passageHash": "7e8dfa1ea2d98d9435dc5d022ca573f8e504a544763d9c1053e0b36753ca27bf" } } ], "derivedFrom": [], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Checked against the pinned dialogue/stage directions. This review is not independent literary peer review." } }, { "id": "p-model", "layer": "interpretation", "kind": "INFERRED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-quest", "p-plea", "p-testimony", "p-recognition", "p-catastrophe" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Finite testimony-to-recognition model. Replay rules are editorial assumptions, not universal causal laws." } }, { "id": "p-recognition-model", "layer": "interpretation", "kind": "INFERRED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-plea", "p-recognition", "p-catastrophe" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Oedipus recognition is explicit; Jocasta’s earlier recognition is an interpretation of her plea and later report. Reporting and acceptance remain separate." } }, { "id": "p-initial-model", "layer": "interpretation", "kind": "INFERRED", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-memory", "p-testimony" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Initial belief, explicit identity uncertainty and the Shepherd’s memory are reconstructed from later recollection; no earlier omniscience is assumed." } }, { "id": "p-intervention", "layer": "counterfactual", "kind": "COUNTERFACTUAL", "sources": [ { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2158, 2226 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2158-L2226", "passageHash": "fd1d2163a51b7f871437c3b1a81a29b554b65a0889cd7edb2988cfb0b520a7ab" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2383, 2490 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2383-L2490", "passageHash": "f2762c9bdaae3f707725878a8a5e97061baf1240ed7092e1fdf9823d3c1e0f2a" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2493, 2498 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2493-L2498", "passageHash": "f53686540a111890a1d0b8df4a6a20f4bad50f30f85e451b7a0ed8294dd297ed" } }, { "sourceEdition": "storr-pg31-2022", "sourceReference": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/31/pg31.txt", "sourceLocation": { "lines": [ 2561, 2644 ], "anchor": "pg31-L2561-L2644", "passageHash": "f4ae4ed7405b344e92d85c06d8c2d9a7442626c87c11fbe1f7b9b42269ad4d75" } } ], "derivedFrom": [ "p-testimony", "p-model" ], "interpretationVersion": "model-a/v0.1", "review": { "status": "reviewed", "reviewer": "Codex source-and-consistency review, 2026-09-15", "note": "Delay only the final Shepherd information transfer until after the modeled horizon. Refusal is textually attested; duration and continued withholding are a curated perturbation, not a sourced alternate history." } } ], "characters": [ { "id": "oedipus", "label": "Oedipus", "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "name": "Oedipus", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "jocasta", "label": "Jocasta", "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "name": "Jocasta", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "tiresias", "label": "Tiresias (Teiresias)", "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "name": "Tiresias (Teiresias)", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "creon", "label": "Creon", "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "name": "Creon", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "messenger", "label": "Corinthian Messenger", "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "name": "Corinthian Messenger", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "shepherd", "label": "Shepherd (Herd of Laius)", "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "name": "Shepherd (Herd of Laius)", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "laius", "label": "Laius", "provenance": [ "p-crossroads" ], "name": "Laius", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "polybus", "label": "Polybus", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "name": "Polybus", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] }, { "id": "second-messenger", "label": "Second Messenger", "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "name": "Second Messenger", "structuralRoles": [], "desires": [], "duties": [], "loyalties": [], "fears": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [] } ], "relationships": [ { "id": "rel-laius", "label": "laius → oedipus: parent-child", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "source": "laius", "target": "oedipus", "type": "parent-child", "direction": "directed", "symmetric": false, "strength": null, "trust": null, "conflict": null, "obligation": null, "scaleVersion": null, "temporalRange": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null } }, { "id": "rel-jocasta", "label": "jocasta → oedipus: parent-child", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "source": "jocasta", "target": "oedipus", "type": "parent-child", "direction": "directed", "symmetric": false, "strength": null, "trust": null, "conflict": null, "obligation": null, "scaleVersion": null, "temporalRange": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null } }, { "id": "rel-marriage", "label": "oedipus → jocasta: spouse", "provenance": [ "p-kin" ], "source": "oedipus", "target": "jocasta", "type": "spouse", "direction": "undirected", "symmetric": true, "strength": null, "trust": null, "conflict": null, "obligation": null, "scaleVersion": null, "temporalRange": { "from": "h-marriage", "until": null } }, { "id": "rel-sibling", "label": "jocasta → creon: sibling", "provenance": [ "p-kin" ], "source": "jocasta", "target": "creon", "type": "sibling", "direction": "undirected", "symmetric": true, "strength": null, "trust": null, "conflict": null, "obligation": null, "scaleVersion": null, "temporalRange": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null } } ], "facts": [ { "id": "f-parentage", "label": "Oedipus is the child of Laius and Jocasta", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "predicate": "child-of", "arguments": [ "oedipus", "laius", "jocasta" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null }, "establishedAt": "t8" }, { "id": "f-polybus", "label": "Polybus is Oedipus’s biological father", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "predicate": "biological-parent", "arguments": [ "polybus", "oedipus" ], "truth": "false", "validDuring": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-killer", "label": "Oedipus killed Laius", "provenance": [ "p-recognition" ], "predicate": "killed", "arguments": [ "oedipus", "laius" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-crossroads", "until": null }, "establishedAt": "t8" }, { "id": "f-marriage", "label": "Oedipus is married to Jocasta", "provenance": [ "p-kin" ], "predicate": "married", "arguments": [ "oedipus", "jocasta" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-marriage", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-oracle", "label": "Punishing Laius’s killer will end the pollution", "provenance": [ "p-oracle" ], "predicate": "purification-command", "arguments": [], "truth": "undetermined", "validDuring": { "from": "t1", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-robbers", "label": "A band of robbers killed Laius", "provenance": [ "p-robbers" ], "predicate": "multiple-killers", "arguments": [ "laius" ], "truth": "undetermined", "validDuring": { "from": "h-crossroads", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-crossroads", "label": "Laius was killed at a meeting of three roads", "provenance": [ "p-crossroads", "p-memory", "p-recognition" ], "predicate": "crossroads-death", "arguments": [ "laius" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-crossroads", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-memory", "label": "Oedipus killed a man at the crossroads", "provenance": [ "p-memory" ], "predicate": "crossroads-killing", "arguments": [ "oedipus" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-crossroads", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-adoption", "label": "Messenger gave the infant Oedipus to Polybus", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "predicate": "gave-child", "arguments": [ "messenger", "oedipus", "polybus" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-handover", "label": "Shepherd gave the infant to the Messenger", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "predicate": "gave-child", "arguments": [ "shepherd", "oedipus", "messenger" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-prophecy", "label": "Oedipus reports a prophecy of patricide and incest", "provenance": [ "p-prophecy" ], "predicate": "prophecy-reported", "arguments": [ "oedipus" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "h-birth", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null }, { "id": "f-polybus-dead", "label": "Polybus has died", "provenance": [ "p-polybus-dead" ], "predicate": "dead", "arguments": [ "polybus" ], "truth": "true", "validDuring": { "from": "t5", "until": null }, "establishedAt": null } ], "epistemicAssertions": [ { "id": "a-polybus", "label": "oedipus: believes f-polybus", "provenance": [ "p-initial-model" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-polybus", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "believes", "validDuring": { "from": "t0", "until": "t5" }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-identity-unknown", "label": "oedipus: explicit-unknown f-parentage", "provenance": [ "p-initial-model" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-parentage", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "explicit-unknown", "validDuring": { "from": "t0", "until": "t8" }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "label": "shepherd: remembers f-handover", "provenance": [ "p-initial-model" ], "holder": "shepherd", "fact": "f-handover", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "remembers", "validDuring": { "from": "t0", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-oracle", "label": "oedipus: reported f-oracle", "provenance": [ "p-oracle" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-oracle", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t1", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-oracle" }, { "id": "a-robbers", "label": "oedipus: reported f-robbers", "provenance": [ "p-robbers" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-robbers", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t1", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-oracle" }, { "id": "a-accused", "label": "oedipus: reported f-killer", "provenance": [ "p-accusation" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-killer", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t3", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-tiresias" }, { "id": "a-denial", "label": "oedipus: believes f-killer", "provenance": [ "p-accusation" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-killer", "polarity": "negative", "mode": "believes", "validDuring": { "from": "t3", "until": "t4" }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-crossroads", "label": "oedipus: reported f-crossroads", "provenance": [ "p-crossroads" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-crossroads", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t4", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-jocasta" }, { "id": "a-memory", "label": "oedipus: remembers f-memory", "provenance": [ "p-memory" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-memory", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "remembers", "validDuring": { "from": "t4", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-prophecy", "label": "jocasta: reported f-prophecy", "provenance": [ "p-prophecy" ], "holder": "jocasta", "fact": "f-prophecy", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t4", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-prophecy" }, { "id": "a-polybus-dead", "label": "oedipus: reported f-polybus-dead", "provenance": [ "p-polybus-dead" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-polybus-dead", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t5", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-messenger" }, { "id": "a-adoption-report", "label": "oedipus: reported f-adoption", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-adoption", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t5", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-messenger" }, { "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "label": "oedipus: believes f-adoption", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-adoption", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "believes", "validDuring": { "from": "t5", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-handover-report", "label": "oedipus: reported f-handover", "provenance": [ "p-handover" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-handover", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t5", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-messenger" }, { "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "label": "jocasta: infers f-parentage", "provenance": [ "p-recognition-model" ], "holder": "jocasta", "fact": "f-parentage", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "infers", "validDuring": { "from": "t6", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-parentage-report", "label": "oedipus: reported f-parentage", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-parentage", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "reported", "validDuring": { "from": "t7", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": "tr-shepherd" }, { "id": "a-identity-known", "label": "oedipus: knows f-parentage", "provenance": [ "p-recognition-model" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-parentage", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "knows", "validDuring": { "from": "t8", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null }, { "id": "a-killer-known", "label": "oedipus: knows f-killer", "provenance": [ "p-recognition-model" ], "holder": "oedipus", "fact": "f-killer", "polarity": "positive", "mode": "knows", "validDuring": { "from": "t8", "until": null }, "hiddenFrom": [], "acquiredVia": null } ], "informationTransfers": [ { "id": "tr-oracle", "label": "Oracle and survivor’s report", "provenance": [ "p-oracle", "p-robbers" ], "sender": "creon", "recipient": "oedipus", "content": [ "f-oracle", "f-robbers" ], "sentAt": "t1", "receivedAt": "t1", "accessConditions": [], "resultingAssertions": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "event": "e-oracle" }, { "id": "tr-tiresias", "label": "Accusation, received but not accepted", "provenance": [ "p-accusation" ], "sender": "tiresias", "recipient": "oedipus", "content": [ "f-killer" ], "sentAt": "t3", "receivedAt": "t3", "accessConditions": [], "resultingAssertions": [ "a-accused" ], "event": "e-tiresias" }, { "id": "tr-jocasta", "label": "Crossroads report", "provenance": [ "p-crossroads" ], "sender": "jocasta", "recipient": "oedipus", "content": [ "f-crossroads" ], "sentAt": "t4", "receivedAt": "t4", "accessConditions": [], "resultingAssertions": [ "a-crossroads" ], "event": "e-crossroads" }, { "id": "tr-prophecy", "label": "Oedipus recounts his oracle", "provenance": [ "p-prophecy" ], "sender": "oedipus", "recipient": "jocasta", "content": [ "f-prophecy" ], "sentAt": "t4", "receivedAt": "t4", "accessConditions": [], "resultingAssertions": [ "a-prophecy" ], "event": "e-crossroads" }, { "id": "tr-messenger", "label": "Death, adoption and the handover chain", "provenance": [ "p-adoption", "p-polybus-dead", "p-handover" ], "sender": "messenger", "recipient": "oedipus", "content": [ "f-polybus-dead", "f-adoption", "f-handover" ], "sentAt": "t5", "receivedAt": "t5", "accessConditions": [], "resultingAssertions": [ "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "event": "e-messenger" }, { "id": "tr-shepherd", "label": "Final parentage testimony", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "sender": "shepherd", "recipient": "oedipus", "content": [ "f-parentage" ], "sentAt": "t7", "receivedAt": "t7", "accessConditions": [ "a-shepherd-memory" ], "resultingAssertions": [ "a-parentage-report" ], "event": "e-testimony" } ], "events": [ { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "provenance": [ "p-oracle", "p-robbers" ], "participants": [ "creon", "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t1", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-oracle" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "creon", "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "provenance": [ "p-quest" ], "participants": [ "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-oracle" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t2", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-quest" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "provenance": [ "p-accusation" ], "participants": [ "tiresias", "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-quest" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t3", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-accusation" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "tiresias", "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "provenance": [ "p-memory", "p-crossroads" ], "participants": [ "jocasta", "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-quest" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t4", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-memory" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "jocasta", "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "participants": [ "messenger", "jocasta", "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-crossroads" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t5", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-adoption" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "messenger", "jocasta", "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "provenance": [ "p-plea" ], "participants": [ "jocasta", "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-messenger" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t6", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-plea" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "jocasta", "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "participants": [ "shepherd", "messenger", "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-persist" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t7", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-testimony" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "shepherd", "messenger", "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "provenance": [ "p-recognition" ], "participants": [ "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-testimony" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t8", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-recognition" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "provenance": [ "p-catastrophe" ], "participants": [ "second-messenger" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-recognition" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t9", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-catastrophe" ], "reversibility": "irreversible", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "second-messenger" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } }, { "id": "e-wait", "label": "Investigation remains awaiting the final testimony", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "participants": [ "oedipus" ], "prerequisites": [ "e-persist" ], "causes": [], "consequences": [], "temporalPosition": { "from": "t8", "until": null }, "narratedAt": [ "d-plea" ], "reversibility": "unknown", "visibility": { "witnessedBy": [ "oedipus" ], "reportedTo": [], "explicitlyUnknownTo": [], "misunderstoodBy": [], "audienceProfiles": [], "assertionRefs": [] } } ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "label": "Begin the investigation", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "actor": "oedipus", "at": "t2", "availableOptions": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "label": "Investigate the reported crime", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "action": "opt-investigate", "availableWhen": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true }, "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-oracle" ], "consequences": [] } ], "chosenAction": "opt-investigate", "beliefState": [], "knowledgeAvailable": [], "knowledgeUnavailable": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [], "consequences": [], "selectionPolicy": [ "opt-investigate" ] }, { "id": "decision-persist", "label": "Continue despite the plea", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "actor": "oedipus", "at": "t6", "availableOptions": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "label": "Pursue the parentage evidence", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "action": "opt-persist", "availableWhen": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true }, "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "consequences": [] } ], "chosenAction": "opt-persist", "beliefState": [], "knowledgeAvailable": [], "knowledgeUnavailable": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [], "consequences": [], "selectionPolicy": [ "opt-persist" ] }, { "id": "decision-response", "label": "Response to final testimony availability", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "actor": "oedipus", "at": "t8", "availableOptions": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "label": "Accept the corroborated identity", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "action": "opt-recognize", "availableWhen": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true }, "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-parentage-report", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "consequences": [] }, { "id": "opt-wait", "label": "Await missing testimony", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "action": "opt-wait", "availableWhen": { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true } }, "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-handover-report" ], "consequences": [] } ], "chosenAction": "opt-recognize", "beliefState": [], "knowledgeAvailable": [], "knowledgeUnavailable": [], "goals": [], "constraints": [], "consequences": [], "selectionPolicy": [ "opt-recognize", "opt-wait" ] } ], "timeline": [ { "id": "h-birth", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": -3, "before": [ "h-crossroads" ], "label": "Birth and transfer of the child" }, { "id": "h-crossroads", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": -2, "before": [ "h-marriage" ], "label": "Killing before accession" }, { "id": "h-marriage", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": -1, "before": [ "t0" ], "label": "Marriage before the opening" }, { "id": "t0", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 0, "before": [ "t1" ], "label": "Opening: a city in distress" }, { "id": "t1", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 1, "before": [ "t2" ], "label": "Creon reports the oracle" }, { "id": "t2", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2, "before": [ "t3" ], "label": "Investigation undertaken" }, { "id": "t3", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 3, "before": [ "t4" ], "label": "Tiresias accuses Oedipus" }, { "id": "t4", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 4, "before": [ "t5" ], "label": "Crossroads account and memory" }, { "id": "t5", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 5, "before": [ "t6" ], "label": "Messenger reveals adoption" }, { "id": "t6", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 6, "before": [ "t7", "u-jocasta-death" ], "label": "Jocasta pleads; Oedipus persists" }, { "id": "t7", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 7, "before": [ "t8" ], "label": "Shepherd’s final testimony" }, { "id": "t8", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 8, "before": [ "t9" ], "label": "Recognition or waiting" }, { "id": "t9", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 9, "before": [ "t10" ], "label": "Catastrophe report / model boundary" }, { "id": "t10", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 10, "before": [ "t11" ], "label": "Evaluation horizon" }, { "id": "t11", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 11, "before": [], "label": "Deferred testimony, beyond horizon" }, { "id": "u-jocasta-death", "axis": "story", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": null, "bounds": [ 6, 9 ], "before": [ "t9" ], "label": "Jocasta’s death: after departure, before discovery; order relative to recognition unknown" }, { "id": "d-cast", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 85, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L85–98" }, { "id": "d-creon", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 184, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L184–193" }, { "id": "d-oracle", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 233, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L233–284" }, { "id": "d-robbers", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 302, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L302–314" }, { "id": "d-quest", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 337, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L337–351" }, { "id": "d-accusation", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 675, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L675–731" }, { "id": "d-plot", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 769, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L769–779" }, { "id": "d-kin", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 1245, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L1245–1264" }, { "id": "d-crossroads", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 1428, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L1428–1478" }, { "id": "d-memory", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 1579, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L1579–1640" }, { "id": "d-summon", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 1689, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L1689–1697" }, { "id": "d-polybus-dead", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 1830, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L1830–1884" }, { "id": "d-prophecy", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 1947, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L1947–1953" }, { "id": "d-adoption", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2006, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2006–2047" }, { "id": "d-feet", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2074, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2074–2113" }, { "id": "d-handover", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2116, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2116–2155" }, { "id": "d-plea", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2158, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2158–2226" }, { "id": "d-shepherd", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2248, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2248–2346" }, { "id": "d-testimony", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2383, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2383–2490" }, { "id": "d-recognition", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2493, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2493–2498" }, { "id": "d-catastrophe", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2561, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2561–2644" }, { "id": "d-ending", "axis": "discourse", "unit": "checkpoint", "coordinate": 2952, "before": [], "label": "Pinned text L2952–3012" } ], "initialState": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "initialAssertions": [ "a-polybus", "a-identity-unknown", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "immutableVariables": [ "history-killing", "history-marriage" ], "timingPolicy": { "version": "policy-v0.1", "allowed": [ { "intervention": "delay-shepherd", "transfer": "tr-shepherd", "forkAt": "t7", "targets": [ "t11" ] } ] }, "causalRules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "label": "Deliver the oracle report", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t1", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, "effects": [], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-oracle", "decision": null, "selectedOption": null, "actor": null, "actorInformationRequired": [], "assertions": [], "retractAssertions": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] }, { "id": "rule-investigate", "label": "Reported mandate enables investigation", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t2", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true }, "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true } ], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-quest", "decision": "decision-investigate", "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "actor": "oedipus", "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-oracle" ], "assertions": [], "retractAssertions": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-accuse", "label": "Investigation encounters the seer", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t3", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, "effects": [], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-tiresias", "decision": null, "selectedOption": null, "actor": null, "actorInformationRequired": [], "assertions": [ "a-denial" ], "retractAssertions": [], "transfers": [ "tr-tiresias" ] }, { "id": "rule-crossroads", "label": "Account and memory are brought together", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t4", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, "effects": [], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-crossroads", "decision": null, "selectedOption": null, "actor": null, "actorInformationRequired": [], "assertions": [ "a-memory" ], "retractAssertions": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] }, { "id": "rule-messenger", "label": "Receive testimony and separately accept adoption", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t5", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true }, "effects": [], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-messenger", "decision": null, "selectedOption": null, "actor": null, "actorInformationRequired": [], "assertions": [ "a-adoption-accepted" ], "retractAssertions": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] }, { "id": "rule-persist", "label": "Adoption evidence enables continued inquiry", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t6", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ] }, "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true } ], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-persist", "decision": "decision-persist", "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "actor": "oedipus", "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "assertions": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "retractAssertions": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-testimony", "label": "The scheduled testimony supplies the missing identity", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t7", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, "effects": [ { "variable": "testimony", "value": true } ], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-testimony", "decision": null, "selectedOption": null, "actor": null, "actorInformationRequired": [], "assertions": [], "retractAssertions": [], "transfers": [ "tr-shepherd" ] }, { "id": "rule-recognize", "label": "Corroborated testimony enables recognition", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true } ] }, "effects": [ { "variable": "recognized", "value": true } ], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-recognition", "decision": "decision-response", "selectedOption": "opt-recognize", "actor": "oedipus", "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-parentage-report", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "assertions": [ "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known" ], "retractAssertions": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "label": "Withheld testimony leaves inquiry open", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true } } ] }, "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true } ], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-wait", "decision": "decision-response", "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "actor": "oedipus", "actorInformationRequired": [ "a-handover-report" ], "assertions": [], "retractAssertions": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-report", "label": "Canonical reporting branch supported by the completed sequence", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t9", "phase": 0, "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true } ] }, "effects": [ { "variable": "report-supported", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "value": true }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "value": true } ], "category": "trigger", "event": "e-report", "decision": null, "selectedOption": null, "actor": null, "actorInformationRequired": [], "assertions": [], "retractAssertions": [], "transfers": [] } ], "outcomeDefinitions": [ { "id": "outcome-oedipus", "version": "v0.1", "subjects": [ "oedipus", "jocasta" ], "horizon": "t10", "dimensions": [ { "id": "historical-harm", "predicate": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-marriage", "value": true } ] }, "provenance": [ "p-recognition" ] }, { "id": "subsequent-catastrophe", "predicate": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-dead", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "oedipus-blind", "value": true } ] }, "provenance": [ "p-catastrophe" ] } ], "tragicWhen": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-dead", "value": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "oedipus-blind", "value": true } ] }, "completionRequired": [ "report-supported" ], "scope": "Subsequent death and self-blinding within the selected reporting horizon; historical killing and marriage retained separately. No claim about political settlement, exile, or all possible futures." } ], "annotationCoverage": [ { "holder": "oedipus", "facts": [ "f-parentage" ], "during": { "from": "t0", "until": null }, "status": "complete-for-scope" }, { "holder": "jocasta", "facts": [ "f-parentage" ], "during": { "from": "t6", "until": null }, "status": "partial" } ], "baselineExpected": { "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "assertions": [ "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known" ], "finalState": { "recognized": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "waiting": false }, "verdict": "tragic" } }, "ontology": { "version": "v0.1", "relations": [ { "id": "parent-child", "symmetric": false, "source": "character", "target": "character" }, { "id": "spouse", "symmetric": true, "source": "character", "target": "character" }, { "id": "sibling", "symmetric": true, "source": "character", "target": "character" } ], "predicates": [ { "id": "child-of", "arity": 3 }, { "id": "biological-parent", "arity": 2 }, { "id": "killed", "arity": 2 }, { "id": "married", "arity": 2 }, { "id": "purification-command", "arity": 0 }, { "id": "multiple-killers", "arity": 1 }, { "id": "crossroads-death", "arity": 1 }, { "id": "crossroads-killing", "arity": 1 }, { "id": "gave-child", "arity": 3 }, { "id": "prophecy-reported", "arity": 1 }, { "id": "dead", "arity": 1 } ], "roles": [] }, "intervention": { "id": "delay-shepherd", "label": "Withhold the final testimony until after the horizon", "provenance": [ "p-intervention" ], "kind": "TIMING", "atomicUnits": [ "delay-final-transfer" ], "tier": "plausible", "preconditions": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true } } ] }, "earliestAt": "t7", "latestAt": "t7", "forkAt": "t7", "operations": [ { "op": "deliver-information", "transfer": "tr-shepherd", "at": "t11" } ], "incompatibleWith": [], "assumptions": [ "The Shepherd continues withholding the final parentage answer; his arrival and the prior investigation are not undone.", "No replacement identity disclosure is introduced within this finite model.", "Absence of the catastrophe report is a loss of inferential support, not proof that Jocasta survives or Oedipus remains unharmed." ], "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1" }, "baseline": { "id": "canonical", "status": "complete", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-canonical-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-denial", "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-tiresias" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-denial", "a-accused" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-tiresias" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-messenger" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-persist" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-testimony" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-testimony", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "testimony", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-parentage-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-shepherd" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-recognition" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": true, "available": false, "selected": false } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-parentage-report", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": "opt-recognize", "effects": [ { "variable": "recognized", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-report" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "report-supported", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "value": true }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-canonical-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": true, "recognized": true, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": true, "jocasta-dead": true, "oedipus-blind": true, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": true, "event:e-recognition": true, "event:e-report": true, "event:e-wait": false }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-known", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-killer-known", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-parentage-report", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "tragic", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "true" } }, "issues": [] }, "transformed": { "id": "variant", "status": "unresolved", "steps": [ { "id": "trace-variant-t0-0", "at": "t0", "coordinate": 0, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": false, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-polybus", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t1-0", "at": "t1", "coordinate": 1, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": false, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": false, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-oracle" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "history-killing", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-oracle", "a-robbers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-oracle" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t2-0", "at": "t2", "coordinate": 2, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": false, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-quest" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "options": [ { "id": "opt-investigate", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-investigate", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-oracle", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [ "a-oracle" ], "selectedOption": "opt-investigate", "effects": [ { "variable": "investigating", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-quest", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t3-0", "at": "t3", "coordinate": 3, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": false, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-denial", "a-identity-unknown", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-tiresias" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-accuse", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-tiresias", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-denial", "a-accused" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [ "tr-tiresias" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t4-0", "at": "t4", "coordinate": 4, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": false, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-crossroads", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-crossroads" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-crossroads", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-memory", "a-crossroads", "a-prophecy" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-denial" ], "transfers": [ "tr-jocasta", "tr-prophecy" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t5-0", "at": "t5", "coordinate": 5, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": false, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": false, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": false, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-messenger" ], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-messenger", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-crossroads", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [ { "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-polybus-dead", "a-adoption-report", "a-handover-report" ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-polybus" ], "transfers": [ "tr-messenger" ] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t6-0", "at": "t6", "coordinate": 6, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-persist" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-persist", "options": [ { "id": "opt-persist", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-persist", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "investigating", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "event:e-messenger", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-persist", "effects": [ { "variable": "persisting", "value": true }, { "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-persist", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-jocasta-infers" ], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t7-0", "at": "t7", "coordinate": 7, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": false, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": false }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t8-0", "at": "t8", "coordinate": 8, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [ "e-wait" ], "decisions": [ { "id": "decision-response", "options": [ { "id": "opt-recognize", "guard": false, "informationAvailable": false, "available": false, "selected": false }, { "id": "opt-wait", "guard": true, "informationAvailable": true, "available": true, "selected": true } ] } ], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t9-0", "at": "t9", "coordinate": 9, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [ { "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ] }, { "id": "trace-variant-t10-0", "at": "t10", "coordinate": 10, "phase": 0, "state": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "assertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "events": [], "decisions": [], "rules": [] } ], "events": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist", "e-wait" ], "finalState": { "investigating": true, "persisting": true, "testimony": false, "recognized": false, "waiting": true, "jocasta-departed": true, "report-supported": null, "jocasta-dead": null, "oedipus-blind": null, "history-killing": true, "history-marriage": true, "event:e-oracle": true, "event:e-quest": true, "event:e-tiresias": true, "event:e-crossroads": true, "event:e-messenger": true, "event:e-persist": true, "event:e-testimony": false, "event:e-recognition": false, "event:e-report": false, "event:e-wait": true }, "activeAssertions": [ "a-accused", "a-adoption-accepted", "a-adoption-report", "a-crossroads", "a-handover-report", "a-identity-unknown", "a-jocasta-infers", "a-memory", "a-oracle", "a-polybus-dead", "a-prophecy", "a-robbers", "a-shepherd-memory" ], "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } }, "issues": [ "Outcome evidence is incomplete at the declared horizon. Unemitted future reports do not establish survival." ] }, "variant": { "id": "delay-shepherd", "baseHash": "3017a7eec936e6e9288e60a85b991e21b109f5a5e2427d693cdee45616a28da6", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "forkAt": "t7", "interventionIds": [ "delay-shepherd" ], "validation": { "status": "valid", "reasons": [ "source access retained", "timing allowed", "history prefix unchanged", "future replayed" ] }, "traceRef": "trace-variant", "graphDeltaRef": "delta-variant", "outcome": { "definition": "outcome-oedipus", "verdict": "unresolved", "dimensions": { "historical-harm": "true", "subsequent-catastrophe": "undetermined" } } }, "diff": { "removed": [ "e-testimony", "e-recognition", "e-report" ], "added": [ "e-wait" ], "retained": [ "e-oracle", "e-quest", "e-tiresias", "e-crossroads", "e-messenger", "e-persist" ], "changed": [ { "variable": "testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "recognized", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "waiting", "canonical": false, "variant": true }, { "variable": "report-supported", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "jocasta-dead", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "oedipus-blind", "canonical": true, "variant": null }, { "variable": "event:e-testimony", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-recognition", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-report", "canonical": true, "variant": false }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "canonical": false, "variant": true } ], "assertionsRemoved": [ "a-identity-known", "a-killer-known", "a-parentage-report" ], "assertionsAdded": [ "a-identity-unknown" ], "witnesses": [ { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t8-0", "id": "rule-recognize", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false } ], "result": false }, "information": [ "a-adoption-accepted", "a-memory" ], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t8-0", "id": "rule-wait", "status": "fired", "reason": "Guard satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "persisting", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true }, { "op": "not", "arg": { "op": "equals", "variable": "testimony", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, "result": true } ], "result": true }, "information": [ "a-handover-report" ], "selectedOption": "opt-wait", "effects": [ { "variable": "waiting", "value": true }, { "variable": "event:e-wait", "value": true } ], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] }, { "traceRef": "trace-variant-t9-0", "id": "rule-report", "status": "blocked", "reason": "Guard not satisfied", "guard": { "op": "all", "args": [ { "op": "equals", "variable": "recognized", "value": true, "actual": false, "result": false }, { "op": "equals", "variable": "jocasta-departed", "value": true, "actual": true, "result": true } ], "result": false }, "information": [], "selectedOption": null, "effects": [], "assertionsAdded": [], "assertionsRemoved": [], "transfers": [] } ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events." }, "graphs": { "Relationship": { "nodes": [ { "id": "laius", "label": "Laius", "kind": "character", "x": 145, "y": 100, "provenance": [ "p-crossroads" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "oedipus", "label": "Oedipus", "kind": "character", "x": 460, "y": 100, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "jocasta", "label": "Jocasta", "kind": "character", "x": 145, "y": 320, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "creon", "label": "Creon", "kind": "character", "x": 460, "y": 320, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null } ], "edges": [ { "id": "rel-laius", "source": "laius", "target": "oedipus", "label": "parent-child", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "rel-jocasta", "source": "jocasta", "target": "oedipus", "label": "parent-child", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "rel-marriage", "source": "oedipus", "target": "jocasta", "label": "spouse", "provenance": [ "p-kin" ], "directed": false }, { "id": "rel-sibling", "source": "jocasta", "target": "creon", "label": "sibling", "provenance": [ "p-kin" ], "directed": false } ], "width": 620, "height": 500, "coverage": "4 source-supported relationships. Biological parentage is shown retrospectively; it is not everyone’s knowledge." }, "Causal": { "nodes": [ { "id": "rule-oracle", "label": "Deliver the oracle report", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 55, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t1", "event": "e-oracle" }, { "id": "e-oracle", "label": "Creon reports the command and survivor’s account", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 55, "provenance": [ "p-oracle", "p-robbers" ], "at": "t1", "event": "e-oracle" }, { "id": "rule-investigate", "label": "Reported mandate enables investigation", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 149, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t2", "event": "e-quest" }, { "id": "e-quest", "label": "Oedipus undertakes the investigation", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 149, "provenance": [ "p-quest" ], "at": "t2", "event": "e-quest" }, { "id": "rule-accuse", "label": "Investigation encounters the seer", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 243, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t3", "event": "e-tiresias" }, { "id": "e-tiresias", "label": "Tiresias names Oedipus; the accusation is rejected", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 243, "provenance": [ "p-accusation" ], "at": "t3", "event": "e-tiresias" }, { "id": "rule-crossroads", "label": "Account and memory are brought together", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 337, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t4", "event": "e-crossroads" }, { "id": "e-crossroads", "label": "Jocasta’s account triggers Oedipus’s recollection", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 337, "provenance": [ "p-memory", "p-crossroads" ], "at": "t4", "event": "e-crossroads" }, { "id": "rule-messenger", "label": "Receive testimony and separately accept adoption", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 431, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t5", "event": "e-messenger" }, { "id": "e-messenger", "label": "Messenger’s testimony challenges assumed parentage", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 431, "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "at": "t5", "event": "e-messenger" }, { "id": "rule-persist", "label": "Adoption evidence enables continued inquiry", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 525, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t6", "event": "e-persist" }, { "id": "e-persist", "label": "Oedipus persists after Jocasta’s plea", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 525, "provenance": [ "p-plea" ], "at": "t6", "event": "e-persist" }, { "id": "rule-testimony", "label": "The scheduled testimony supplies the missing identity", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 619, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t7", "event": "e-testimony" }, { "id": "e-testimony", "label": "Shepherd identifies the child’s household", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 619, "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "at": "t7", "event": "e-testimony" }, { "id": "rule-recognize", "label": "Corroborated testimony enables recognition", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 713, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "event": "e-recognition" }, { "id": "e-recognition", "label": "Oedipus acknowledges identity and patricide", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 713, "provenance": [ "p-recognition" ], "at": "t8", "event": "e-recognition" }, { "id": "rule-wait", "label": "Withheld testimony leaves inquiry open", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 807, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "event": "e-wait" }, { "id": "e-wait", "label": "Investigation remains awaiting the final testimony", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 807, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "event": "e-wait" }, { "id": "rule-report", "label": "Canonical reporting branch supported by the completed sequence", "kind": "rule", "x": 190, "y": 901, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t9", "event": "e-report" }, { "id": "e-report", "label": "Second Messenger reports death and self-blinding", "kind": "event", "x": 485, "y": 901, "provenance": [ "p-catastrophe" ], "at": "t9", "event": "e-report" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "edge-rule-oracle", "source": "rule-oracle", "target": "e-oracle", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-investigate", "source": "rule-investigate", "target": "e-quest", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-investigate-e-oracle", "source": "e-oracle", "target": "rule-investigate", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-accuse", "source": "rule-accuse", "target": "e-tiresias", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-accuse-e-quest", "source": "e-quest", "target": "rule-accuse", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-crossroads", "source": "rule-crossroads", "target": "e-crossroads", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-crossroads-e-quest", "source": "e-quest", "target": "rule-crossroads", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-messenger", "source": "rule-messenger", "target": "e-messenger", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-messenger-e-crossroads", "source": "e-crossroads", "target": "rule-messenger", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-persist", "source": "rule-persist", "target": "e-persist", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-persist-e-messenger", "source": "e-messenger", "target": "rule-persist", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-testimony", "source": "rule-testimony", "target": "e-testimony", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-testimony-e-persist", "source": "e-persist", "target": "rule-testimony", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-recognize", "source": "rule-recognize", "target": "e-recognition", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-recognize-e-testimony", "source": "e-testimony", "target": "rule-recognize", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-wait", "source": "rule-wait", "target": "e-wait", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-wait-e-persist", "source": "e-persist", "target": "rule-wait", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "edge-rule-report", "source": "rule-report", "target": "e-report", "label": "enables", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "guard-rule-report-e-recognition", "source": "e-recognition", "target": "rule-report", "label": "requires", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true } ], "width": 640, "height": 1030, "coverage": "Finite rule incidence graph. Guards retain all / any / not logic in the evidence panel. No universal causal claim." }, "Epistemic": { "nodes": [ { "id": "oedipus", "label": "Oedipus", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 50, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "jocasta", "label": "Jocasta", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 136, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "tiresias", "label": "Tiresias (Teiresias)", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 222, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "creon", "label": "Creon", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 308, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "messenger", "label": "Corinthian Messenger", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 394, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "shepherd", "label": "Shepherd (Herd of Laius)", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 480, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "laius", "label": "Laius", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 566, "provenance": [ "p-crossroads" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "polybus", "label": "Polybus", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 652, "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "second-messenger", "label": "Second Messenger", "kind": "character", "x": 125, "y": 738, "provenance": [ "p-cast" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-parentage", "label": "Oedipus is the child of Laius and Jocasta", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 50, "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-polybus", "label": "Polybus is Oedipus’s biological father", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 136, "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-killer", "label": "Oedipus killed Laius", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 222, "provenance": [ "p-recognition" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-marriage", "label": "Oedipus is married to Jocasta", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 308, "provenance": [ "p-kin" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-oracle", "label": "Punishing Laius’s killer will end the pollution", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 394, "provenance": [ "p-oracle" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-robbers", "label": "A band of robbers killed Laius", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 480, "provenance": [ "p-robbers" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-crossroads", "label": "Laius was killed at a meeting of three roads", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 566, "provenance": [ "p-crossroads", "p-memory", "p-recognition" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-memory", "label": "Oedipus killed a man at the crossroads", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 652, "provenance": [ "p-memory" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-adoption", "label": "Messenger gave the infant Oedipus to Polybus", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 738, "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-handover", "label": "Shepherd gave the infant to the Messenger", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 824, "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-prophecy", "label": "Oedipus reports a prophecy of patricide and incest", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 910, "provenance": [ "p-prophecy" ], "at": null, "event": null }, { "id": "f-polybus-dead", "label": "Polybus has died", "kind": "fact", "x": 465, "y": 996, "provenance": [ "p-polybus-dead" ], "at": null, "event": null } ], "edges": [ { "id": "a-polybus", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-polybus", "label": "believes", "provenance": [ "p-initial-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-identity-unknown", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-parentage", "label": "explicit-unknown", "provenance": [ "p-initial-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-shepherd-memory", "source": "shepherd", "target": "f-handover", "label": "remembers", "provenance": [ "p-initial-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-oracle", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-oracle", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-oracle" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-robbers", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-robbers", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-robbers" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-accused", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-killer", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-accusation" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-denial", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-killer", "label": "believes (negative)", "provenance": [ "p-accusation" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-crossroads", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-crossroads", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-crossroads" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-memory", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-memory", "label": "remembers", "provenance": [ "p-memory" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-prophecy", "source": "jocasta", "target": "f-prophecy", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-prophecy" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-polybus-dead", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-polybus-dead", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-polybus-dead" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-adoption-report", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-adoption", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-adoption-accepted", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-adoption", "label": "believes", "provenance": [ "p-adoption" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-handover-report", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-handover", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-handover" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-jocasta-infers", "source": "jocasta", "target": "f-parentage", "label": "infers", "provenance": [ "p-recognition-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-parentage-report", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-parentage", "label": "reported", "provenance": [ "p-testimony" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-identity-known", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-parentage", "label": "knows", "provenance": [ "p-recognition-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "a-killer-known", "source": "oedipus", "target": "f-killer", "label": "knows", "provenance": [ "p-recognition-model" ], "directed": true } ], "width": 640, "height": 1092, "coverage": "Only published annotations are drawn. No edge means annotation missing, not ignorance. Modes and polarity are written on every edge." }, "Decision": { "nodes": [ { "id": "decision-investigate", "label": "Begin the investigation", "kind": "decision", "x": 150, "y": 85, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t2", "event": null }, { "id": "opt-investigate", "label": "Investigate the reported crime", "kind": "option", "x": 475, "y": 65, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t2", "event": "e-quest" }, { "id": "decision-persist", "label": "Continue despite the plea", "kind": "decision", "x": 150, "y": 245, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t6", "event": null }, { "id": "opt-persist", "label": "Pursue the parentage evidence", "kind": "option", "x": 475, "y": 225, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t6", "event": "e-persist" }, { "id": "decision-response", "label": "Response to final testimony availability", "kind": "decision", "x": 150, "y": 405, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "event": null }, { "id": "opt-recognize", "label": "Accept the corroborated identity", "kind": "option", "x": 475, "y": 385, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "event": "e-recognition" }, { "id": "opt-wait", "label": "Await missing testimony", "kind": "option", "x": 475, "y": 450, "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "at": "t8", "event": "e-wait" } ], "edges": [ { "id": "choice-opt-investigate", "source": "decision-investigate", "target": "opt-investigate", "label": "available if guard + information", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "choice-opt-persist", "source": "decision-persist", "target": "opt-persist", "label": "available if guard + information", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "choice-opt-recognize", "source": "decision-response", "target": "opt-recognize", "label": "available if guard + information", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true }, { "id": "choice-opt-wait", "source": "decision-response", "target": "opt-wait", "label": "available if guard + information", "provenance": [ "p-model" ], "directed": true } ], "width": 640, "height": 560, "coverage": "Options are selected by a reviewed finite policy and actor information. Waiting is a model state, not invented dialogue." } }, "metrics": { "canonical": [ { "metric": "recognition-delay", "status": "computed", "value": 5, "numerator": 5, "denominator": 1, "unit": "ordinal checkpoints", "inputs": [ { "id": "oedipus-rex", "version": "v0.1", "hash": "3017a7eec936e6e9288e60a85b991e21b109f5a5e2427d693cdee45616a28da6" } ], "engineVersion": "0.1.0", "algorithmVersion": "0.1.0", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "mappingRefs": [], "traceRefs": [ "trace-canonical-t0-0", "trace-canonical-t1-0", "trace-canonical-t2-0", "trace-canonical-t3-0", "trace-canonical-t4-0", "trace-canonical-t5-0", "trace-canonical-t6-0", "trace-canonical-t7-0", "trace-canonical-t8-0", "trace-canonical-t9-0", "trace-canonical-t10-0" ], "witnessRefs": [ "trace-canonical-t3-0", "trace-canonical-t8-0" ], "assumptions": [ "Measured from first received accusation of f-killer to explicit knowledge of that same fact.", "Ordinal intervals are model checkpoints, not equal elapsed durations.", "No completed recognition within the horizon produces null, never zero." ], "scope": "Oedipus / f-killer / t0–t10", "coverage": { "annotatedFacts": 12, "modeledEvents": 10 }, "exactness": "exact-for-inputs" }, { "metric": "trace-evidence-count", "status": "computed", "value": 9, "numerator": 9, "denominator": 10, "unit": "fired rules", "inputs": [ { "id": "oedipus-rex", "version": "v0.1", "hash": "3017a7eec936e6e9288e60a85b991e21b109f5a5e2427d693cdee45616a28da6" } ], "engineVersion": "0.1.0", "algorithmVersion": "0.1.0", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "mappingRefs": [], "traceRefs": [ "trace-canonical-t0-0", "trace-canonical-t1-0", "trace-canonical-t2-0", "trace-canonical-t3-0", "trace-canonical-t4-0", "trace-canonical-t5-0", "trace-canonical-t6-0", "trace-canonical-t7-0", "trace-canonical-t8-0", "trace-canonical-t9-0", "trace-canonical-t10-0" ], "witnessRefs": [ "trace-canonical-t1-0", "trace-canonical-t2-0", "trace-canonical-t3-0", "trace-canonical-t4-0", "trace-canonical-t5-0", "trace-canonical-t6-0", "trace-canonical-t7-0", "trace-canonical-t8-0", "trace-canonical-t9-0" ], "assumptions": [ "Count is computational coverage, not strength or literary confidence." ], "scope": "The ten declared rule candidates through t10", "coverage": { "annotatedFacts": 12, "modeledEvents": 10 }, "exactness": "exact-for-inputs" } ], "variant": [ { "metric": "recognition-delay", "status": "unresolved", "value": null, "numerator": null, "denominator": null, "unit": "ordinal checkpoints", "inputs": [ { "id": "oedipus-rex", "version": "v0.1", "hash": "3017a7eec936e6e9288e60a85b991e21b109f5a5e2427d693cdee45616a28da6" } ], "engineVersion": "0.1.0", "algorithmVersion": "0.1.0", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "mappingRefs": [], "traceRefs": [ "trace-variant-t0-0", "trace-variant-t1-0", "trace-variant-t2-0", "trace-variant-t3-0", "trace-variant-t4-0", "trace-variant-t5-0", "trace-variant-t6-0", "trace-variant-t7-0", "trace-variant-t8-0", "trace-variant-t9-0", "trace-variant-t10-0" ], "witnessRefs": [ "trace-variant-t3-0" ], "assumptions": [ "Measured from first received accusation of f-killer to explicit knowledge of that same fact.", "Ordinal intervals are model checkpoints, not equal elapsed durations.", "No completed recognition within the horizon produces null, never zero." ], "scope": "Oedipus / f-killer / t0–t10", "coverage": { "annotatedFacts": 12, "modeledEvents": 10 }, "exactness": "exact-for-inputs" }, { "metric": "trace-evidence-count", "status": "computed", "value": 7, "numerator": 7, "denominator": 10, "unit": "fired rules", "inputs": [ { "id": "oedipus-rex", "version": "v0.1", "hash": "3017a7eec936e6e9288e60a85b991e21b109f5a5e2427d693cdee45616a28da6" } ], "engineVersion": "0.1.0", "algorithmVersion": "0.1.0", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "mappingRefs": [], "traceRefs": [ "trace-variant-t0-0", "trace-variant-t1-0", "trace-variant-t2-0", "trace-variant-t3-0", "trace-variant-t4-0", "trace-variant-t5-0", "trace-variant-t6-0", "trace-variant-t7-0", "trace-variant-t8-0", "trace-variant-t9-0", "trace-variant-t10-0" ], "witnessRefs": [ "trace-variant-t1-0", "trace-variant-t2-0", "trace-variant-t3-0", "trace-variant-t4-0", "trace-variant-t5-0", "trace-variant-t6-0", "trace-variant-t8-0" ], "assumptions": [ "Count is computational coverage, not strength or literary confidence." ], "scope": "The ten declared rule candidates through t10", "coverage": { "annotatedFacts": 12, "modeledEvents": 10 }, "exactness": "exact-for-inputs" }, { "metric": "variant-structural-delta", "status": "computed", "value": 4, "numerator": 4, "denominator": 10, "unit": "event membership edits", "inputs": [ { "id": "oedipus-rex", "version": "v0.1", "hash": "3017a7eec936e6e9288e60a85b991e21b109f5a5e2427d693cdee45616a28da6" } ], "engineVersion": "0.1.0", "algorithmVersion": "0.1.0", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "policyVersion": "policy-v0.1", "mappingRefs": [], "traceRefs": [ "trace-variant-t0-0", "trace-variant-t1-0", "trace-variant-t2-0", "trace-variant-t3-0", "trace-variant-t4-0", "trace-variant-t5-0", "trace-variant-t6-0", "trace-variant-t7-0", "trace-variant-t8-0", "trace-variant-t9-0", "trace-variant-t10-0" ], "witnessRefs": [ "trace-variant-t8-0", "trace-variant-t8-0", "trace-variant-t9-0" ], "assumptions": [ "Counts symmetric difference of emitted event IDs.", "An absent report is not a prevented death.", "Both runs use identical event granularity and horizon." ], "scope": "Emitted events and terminal state in the fixed Oedipus model through t10; absent reports are not prevented world events.", "coverage": { "annotatedFacts": 12, "modeledEvents": 10 }, "exactness": "exact-for-inputs" } ] } }